Education
In Madhya Pradesh
By Sachin Kumar Jain
14 July, 2007
Countercurrents.org
If
one wants to get equity and respect in life, then education is the basic
requirement, but in Madhya Pradesh, education itself has turned into
a challenge for the children. In the Nateran block of Vidisha district,
102 out of 282 schools are such where impact of education was not at
all felt in real life. Not a single student in these schools managed
to pass primary level exams. During the academic session that recently
concluded (2006-07), 41 per cent of the children could not get the certificate
of having passed and not a single student of government schools could
make it to the merit list. If school level education does not hold any
importance for the state or society, then the situation of education
system, especially situation of quality education, is looking to be
quite worrisome.
Total 46 percent of the teachers
in state are working without training. The decision to give shikshakarmis
and contract teachers the same grade as regular teachers is a late step
towards equity in the system. Now indeed 1.25 lakh temporary para teachers
would get respect and equity due to them. But the question is whether
this would bring positive changes in quality of education. Government
of Madhya Pradesh in a recent decision has given status of teacher to
the para teachers but still a question of quality and capacity of these
teachers still exists.
It indeed terrifies one to realize that we are encouraging such education
system where the government is literally digging the roots of the society
to promote commercialization in education. There is ample doubt that
an education system that is based on disparity and inequality would
be able to remove the social evils like casteism and communalism from
the minds of the students. The questions that raises head again and
again is that how can a teacher, who is himself/herself untrained provide
good education to children.
At the national and international
level, society and politicians have had to accept that the right to
education is directly connected to the basic right to life. In the World
Education Forum convention at Dakar in Senegal in year 2000, all the
countries in world, including India had claimed unanimously that by
year 2015 education would be provided to all. But the government hardly
seems prepared for the challenges to be addressed to fulfill this promise.
Education can drastically
change the equation between the weak and powerful in the society and
this is one of the main reasons that free, compulsory and quality education
has been opposed. Reformer Gopal Krishna Gokhale had placed a resolution
of free and compulsory education before the Imperial Assembly in year
1911, but owing to the pressure of propagators of capitalist and divisive
politics, the resolution could not be passed. Later in 1937, Mahatma
Gandhi termed education as the basic priority of states and asked the
education ministers to make education `productive'. But this proposal
was almost shot down under the excuse of unavailability of resources.
The situation has not much changed even now. Education is being provided,
but teachers remain absent. There are schools but textbooks and buildings
are not available. If something happens without fail, it is multifaceted
disparity. The World Bank has recently praised the educational efforts
of the MP Government because this institution that seeks to promote
globalisation and capitalism thinks can education could be somehow conducted
with help of temporary teachers. Although shikshakarmis have been given
the cadre of full time teachers, to give them the true honour, it is
important that the teachers are freed of all non-academic work.
MP has had total strength of 117502 para teachers inclusive of contract
teachers, shikshakarmis and temporary teachers like gurujis.
This year, the number would
increase by 50000. The government has decided to use para teachers as
a policy in the garb of providing education to all. But the important
fact is that these para teachers do not have the basic competency in
subjects and teaching techniques. It has been always debated that at
least school level education should be made compulsory, but government
has considered primary and maximum part of middle school education as
part of `compulsory education'. Now since the government is committed
to this, it has come out with strategy to appoint temporary and untrained
teachers at low salaries to cope with the requirement. Important fact
is that about 96000 out of the 1.17-lakh para teachers are working at
middle school level. One third of para teachers in country are in Madhya
Pradesh, the number being highest among all states. The objective seems
to be fulfilling the formalities of `education for all'. In the higher
education sector permanent, full time and trained teachers are working.
This means that rural, tribal, dalit and economically backward students
studying in government schools would get education, but this education
would neither be qualitative nor productive.
In the Jan Sunwai (public
hearing) conducted at Bhopal by MP Shiksha Abhiyan it was proved that
the students of government primary school could just write their names,
which means that they have just become literate and not being educated.
This is clear violation of the constitutional right of equality and
right to education. Recently, after analysing the educational situation
in tribal areas, the government has made a policy to appoint guest teachers.
These would also be temporary teachers who do not need experience and
competence and would be paid on basis of classes taken.
The situation is that about
49200 para teachers are educated only upto higher secondary or even
lower level and about 88000 teachers have no training and these are
the teachers who are posted in rural areas and teach the actually deprived
section of children. These are those children who not only require education
to be able to read and write, but to engage in the process of liberation
from disparity of class and creed. This makes it clear that the government
is either not able to gauge the connection between education and social
reforms, or is not willing to accept the fact.
The experience document of
the Madhya Pradesh Education Campaign mentions that even the most expert
teachers consider teaching primary kids more challenging than those
in higher classes. Yet the responsibility of primary teaching has been
given in incompetent hands. To find a solution to this problem, the
state government has come out with the strategy, under which more than
one lakh untrained teachers are being provided D Ed (diploma in education)
degree by using distance education programme of the MP Bhoj Open University,
while they continue their teaching work. Here too, one point arises
as to how the teachers would get competency without practical training.
Working in the present conditions, the teachers are not in situation
of going through such training. In the state about 30233 (25.06 pc)
schools are such where only one teacher is responsible for teaching,
administration and also the mid-day meal scheme.
If not anything, the state
government should be made aware of the concerns of the Supreme Court.
In a recent ruling in Andhrakesari Educational Society versus, instructors/
schoolteachers, the Supreme Court had made clear that unskilled and
incompetent teachers are dangerous for the educational machinery. In
such situation, the government and the university would have to take
care that inadequate training does not hamper the education for children.
Similarly in a ruling on Mutthukumar versus Tamil Nadu State, the Supreme
Court ruled that the process of untrained teachers teaching children
is detrimental fro the country and would prove to be roadblock in progress
of nation. But the government is so engrossed in commercialization of
education, that it does not even hear the voice of the apex court. It
is the need of the time to turn the issue of education into a mass campaign.
Those who consider private education system as better would have to
understand that they are relieving the government of its constitutional
responsibility and this is very dangerous trend where the state would
have no role to play in society.
Leave
A Comment
&
Share Your Insights
Comment
Policy
Digg
it! And spread the word!
Here is a unique chance to help this article to be read by thousands
of people more. You just Digg it, and it will appear in the home page
of Digg.com and thousands more will read it. Digg is nothing but an
vote, the article with most votes will go to the top of the page. So,
as you read just give a digg and help thousands more to read this article.