Will Have The Last Laugh
By Vidya Bhushan Rawat
31 March, 2007
two judges bench headed by Justice Ajit Parsayat has stayed the 27%
quota meant for the Other Backward Communities in the higher education.
The upper caste Hindus today celebrated Holy and Diwali. After the miserable
failure and huge loss of advertisement by the favorite Indian cricket
team virtually surrendered to Bangladesh and then to Srilanka, the reactions
were similar to that happened to anti Mandal agitation in 1991. If our
memories have not faded, we must revisit the events in Eden Gardens,
Kolkata when the downtrodden Sri Lanka was inflicting a humiliating
defeat and the Bhadralok crowd at Kolkata started throwing paper missiles,
and stones at the Srilankan players. I am afraid, if this World Cup
were being organized in India, the Indian people would not have allowed
Bangladesh to win. That is upper caste nationalism in India. A nationalism,
which does not recognize merit but purely create merit on the basis
of one's caste.
The defeat by the under estimated
Bangladesh spelled a pall of gloom over the market which has been monopolized
by the caste media which had lionized the team without realizing its
real strength. India sunk into gloom (it was not a game but the nation
was already declared world champions) and defeat clearly put the astrologers
also to mat who were predicting super performance from the team. Nevertheless,
despite this entire nonsensical attitude, the irrational astrology still
is the best medicine that the caste Hindus takes. The doctors also have
the same attitude as they have red tilak over their forehead and big
temples outside the ICUs in Delhi. Nothing is irrational and unscientific
as long as the Hindus believe in it. So Muslims become cruel for they
slaughter animals but Hindus become 'non violent' when they slaughter
goats, buffalos and pigs in the temples to please their Gods and Goddesses.
After days of gloom, the
anchors at the TV studios are smiling for a 'historic' judgment of Supreme
Court. Now, they can discuss things and bring the 'cheerleaders' to
their studios suggesting that the 'whole' 'nation' is against reservation.
A few doctors of the All India Institute of Medical Sciences or as I
would like it call All India Institute of Manuwadi Studies have become
'nation' imagination. Based on their assumptions, the Supreme Court
has stayed the order of the reservation for OBCs in the institutions
of higher education, which were always meant for the Brahmins when Manu's
law first defined it. As India moved to secularism and democracy, Manu's
laws became politically though socially they remained as powerful as
ever despite 9% growth rate. Understanding that power of democracy means
power of number and not just democracy for the people but now it has
become 'of' the people and 'by' the people. With the marginalized groups
asserting their number power with more political aggressions, the upper
castes were left with no options except to dilute the entire concept
of social justice through the judicial process, which remain outside
the purview of the quota. Moreover, through privatizing the various
government owned corporations and services, the government has already
nullified the concept of reservation.
Now, after the formation
of Special Economic Zones, the government as well as the courts have
hit on the backbones of our farmers. SEZ have been declared legalized
while people have been uprooted from their nation. Land Reforms have
been made redundant by the continuous protections by the courts. Today,
the politicians use the courts for their own purposes. It is due to
this ambiguity that the courts have now become the most powerful and
uncontrolled institution of the country. A healthy democracy need independent
judiciary and committed governance. Nodoubt, the political leadership
during the past 20 years have reduced to nothing as more criminals taking
lead but the power of the masses is relegated to 'people's representatives'.
Still, even a bad democracy is better than an unaccountable government
or military dictatorship. Ofcourse, this clearly means that it is the
political class which will need to run the country and not the courts
and the bureaucrats which is increasingly becoming the case in India.
Upper castes elite in Delhi
often says that reservation is denying them basic human rights of equality
and hence they are leaving for the United States. Let the courts ask
them to stay in India if they studies in Indian schools. They cannot
go abroad after getting the subsidized education at the premier Indian
educational institutions. The youngsters do not know what is happening
even outside their house. They would not even ask their parent as why
the scavenger who clean their shit and toilet come from one particular
community. This elite would not even know that in India there are places
where people still clean shit and carry night soil. Yes, they are not
interested to know about this.
Shockingly, the judgments
in the past few years reflect of the growing trend to keep the middle
classes happy. We have judges who speak for Hindutva terming it as a
way of life. We have a former Supreme Court Judge who did not implicate
a single politician in the anti Sikh riots in Delhi in 1984 and later
became a Member of Parliament against all the ethics of impartiality
of an institution. Right to Strike was also banned by the Kerala Highcourt,
which was appreciated by the media and industries.
The Judges went overboard
in terming the quotas as vote bank politics. Question is why not vote
bank politics after all what are politicians required to do? Yes, if
they are working for their people than the best one is that who does
not to take care of their constituencies? It is absurd as former Prime
Minister V.P.Singh said about the court order. Parliament passed a bill
unanimously and the court's are terming it as vote bank politics. The
Judges further said that politicians should not divide the country on
the basis of caste and that in India it has become habitual for people
to claim 'backward' status. One need to support V.P.Singh's demand for
a referendum and census based on caste.
It is tragic that the record
of the courts related to social justice and social reform reflect poverty
of ideas and lack of human rights understanding. It is also reflected
that the courts are consciously giving judgments on the basis of media
campaign. A media, which has been thoroughly unprofessional and highly
prejudiced one. Justice Rajendra Sachar had long back stated in a public
meeting that the court buckle under public pressure. Unfortunately,
there is no backward movement in India, which can take on the upper
caste thugs who are destroying India. Except for the forthright stand
of DMK, PMK and other political groups representing the OBCs there is
no one to raise their voice. They remain loyal shudras providing fodder
to Hindutva to kill the Dalits in the villages. It is time for the OBCs
to revolt against their self-serving leaders and get a new leadership
which can give them new ideas and for whom OBC does not mean a family
of their own but the entire community. We need a dynamic leadership
which does not sale farmer's land to corporate houses at the throwaway
prices and have a clear vision to help and upgrade the communities.
Alas, most of them have nothing except their caste. They remember their
people only when they do nothing are defeated in the larger games of
Where are the OBC students
and their political leaders? Tamilnadu has taken the lead in this direction
in a rare gesture of unanimity among the political class. But that unanimity
is not visible in the North at the moment. In UP while every OBC caste
is struggling to get an identity and a share in power but none of them
is raging the issue of reservation in power. The reason behind this
is the absence of the cultural movement among the OBCs. Unlike Tamilnadu
where Periyar launched self respect movement for the OBCs and Dalits,
north Indian OBCs still have not been able to divert their attention
from the ritualistic Hindutva. The political ideas of the OBC leadership
remained prejudicious and anti Dalits. Dalits is good for them as long
as it vote to them but bad if the Dalit take the leadership. OBC leadership
in the north must think that as long as they remain loyal soldiers of
Hindutva as Ambedkar once said, they can not take on the powerful forces
of corporations and religion, who jointly work together to thwart any
new effort which challenges the status quo.
It is said that Periyar and
his followers had no will to come to north and educate their 'illiterate'
backward leaders who remain caged in the brahmanical agenda. Similarly,
portraying Jyoti Ba Phule, as leaders of Bahujans have not worked as
a community called Sainis feels that he was their leader. Kurmis have
gone for Sardar Patel and Rajbhars towards Raja Sohail Dev. This is
the irony of the entire movement in Uttar-Pradesh has been defeated
by the shortsighted caste leaders who have very little to offer to their
communities. They only need a power position and manipulating the sentiments
of their communities. It is not for nothing that in Uttar-Pradesh, which
is going to polls, that all the OBC-Dalit parties are running after
the Brahmins and Thakurs. None of them have come out strongly against
the current judgment of the Supreme Court. Perhaps, the leadership knows
it would be too dangerous to 'offend' the Supreme Court because a majority
of them are under the scanner of the Supreme Court.
More than the courts, Congress
Party's credentials in remain suspect in this regard. It is clear that
with in the party, there is a group of member of Parliaments as well
as Ministers who are opposed to quota for OBCs. One even doubt the credentials
of H R Bhardwaj, the law minister who was brought back from hibernation
for being Sonia loyalist, for his inability to put the government's
case properly in the court. A large number of OBC students who prepared
for the IIMs and IITs have been denied human rights due to an intervention
from the court, which many clearly term as retrogressive.
During the Mandal agitation
and afterwards, it is the Dalits who have been supporting the reservation
for the OBCs but OBC students hardly fought their battle. It is time
for them to wake up and challenge the myth by the brahmanical media.
Yes, I would say it firmly that Indian media remain confined to the
sentiments of their fellow caste men who leave India after getting subsidized
education from the elite institutions of IITs, IIMs and other institutions.
This media does not see the plight of OBCs and MBCs.
It is the fallacy that the
reservations have forced the upper castes to leave India. They had left
India long before and they were using the services of the elite institutions
to benefit their own community since a majority of them cannot afford
to compete with the west on a level playing field.
The Indian Express today
carried a story of Justice Parsayat quoting from the American Judiciary.
The fact of the matter is that American Judicial system worked against
the social justice but still it does not come in way of social justice.
Secondly, in the United States and elsewhere, it is the minority, which
is seeking the rights to be in the governance but in India it ironically
the majority of Bahujans-Dalits who are asking to be given the space
to govern and participate in the democracy. Prof Dipankar Gupta of the
JNU has been in the news recently when he told the United Nations Human
Rights Committee, in Geneva that there is no caste system in India and
that the Kshatriyas, Brahmins, Vaishyas and Shudras do not have separate
identities and they live together with great affection. Gupta has now
come out strong in support of Supreme Court Judgment. Of-course, writing
for mainstream media would not be that easy if you question the very
basis of the Varnadhrama and its notoriety in keeping people subjugated.
Dipankar Gupta is happy at the rational judgment of the Supreme Court
and so are our friends in the media. The die has been caste and the
judgment of the two-judge bench would become difficult for those who
are celebrating today.
It may have been unintentional
but the crude fact is that after the Supreme Court's judgment, it is
imperative for the government to go for a caste census. The upper caste
leaders and bureaucracy has clearly not wanted to go for it, as they
know it would be the last nail in their coffin. That the National Sample
Survey which remains an organization of the upper elites in India could
found 37% the population of the OBCs, and then it is for certain that
the OBC population in Indian has grown much beyond what was in 1931.
Let the government come out with a specific data on the OBC population
and their social status. Just saying that all Yadavas have grown up
because there are Mulayam and Lalu, is the travesty of truth. A majority
of OBCs consisting MBCs whose social status remain as the Dalits. Ofcourse,
these MBCs would always consider themselves higher in the social ladder
despite weak economic strength yet they remain socially and educationally
There are various ways to
measure socio economic ostracisation of the marginalized. And it should
be done but the intention of the ruling party and those claiming 'youth
for equality' is not to demolish the caste system but perpetrate it
and ensure that their relatives and blood brothers remain safer in the
new global world.
It is time not only for referendum but also for a constitutional review.
To ensure that Parliament's supremacy is retained, it is important that
the leaders representing the communities have done their homework well.
So far, there are very few who can speak with strength of their conviction
and challenge. Democracy works on healthy relationship of judiciary
with the Executive and legislature. One does not need moral preaching
from the judges while exonerating themselves from the public scrutiny.
If there is a Lokayukta for the state lagislature, there will have to
be same provision for the judges also. And most importantly, why should
the judiciary remain outside the ambit of quota and social justice.
It is time for all the political parties, jurists, and academic to sit
together and decide. The regular humiliation of merit and non-merit
must stop. The country cannot remain silent when its majority is being
humiliated by those who have no concern for the country and sole interest
remain outside the country. Let us decide once for all, the entire issue
of reservation. So it is also the time to review our constitution, which
can make Parliament Supreme again. The present constitution was drafted
by a legend called Ambedkar but his hands were tied with strong upper
caste feudal presence in the constituent assembly. Let there be a new
committee to look into the problems of the constitution and change it
accordingly as numbers do matters in democracy. You cannot allow courts
striking everything that is public welfare as against the spirit of
Politicians have a lot to
learn from this. No need for taking shelter in Supreme Court for taking
potshots at others to score political goals. Introspecting the mistakes
will help them realize whether it would the executive or the Supreme
Court to run the country as they are doing it today. Their lack of convictions
and moral high ground have given ample ammunition to the courts which
might be unhealthy for democracy in the longer term as every good measure
might be treated as 'vote bank' politics which the politicians are no
doubt involved in. Time for them to look beyond their personal interest
and serve the people.
Vidya Bhushan Rawat
Visit my blog at
For information on the issues,
movements and priorities of Scavenger community in India please log
Contribute your article on
freedom, humanism and human rights to
For Social action, land rights,
right to food and hunger issues support Social Development Foundation
here to comment
on this article