Terrorism's 'Tenkasi' Moment
By Subhash Gatade
20 February,
2008
Countercurrents.org
Tenkasi, called as Kashi of
the South - supposedly for its Kashi Vishvnath temple, part of Tirunelveli
district (Tamil Nadu) witnessed a pipe bomb attack on RSS office on
24 th January at 9 p.m.
Interestingly nobody was injured in the attack as no one was in the office at that time. As can be expected it led to tension in the area with Sangh Parivar organisations coming out on streets demanding action against 'fundamentalist' groups for spreading their tentacles.
It may be noted that the city had witnessed another explosion at Tenkasi
New Bus Stand just before this attack where one person suffered minor
injuries.
Fearing reprisals the police tightened its security.Forensic experts and personnel of Bomb Detection and Disposal Squad (BDDS) personnel rushed in and collected samples from the site. Initial investigation revealed that a low intensity explosive was used.
Senior police officials also rushed to the place and camped in Tenkasi to defuse the tense situation. Looking at the fact that Tenkasi had witnessed communal violence in which six persons were killed in August last year, they did not want to take any chances.
Commenting on the attack, there were editorials in TN papers about the growing nexus of "Islamic Terrorists' in the state and the need to put it down with firmness. The police was even exhorted to be extra vigilant against such enemies of people and was also asked to nab the real purprits
All that is passe now.
And as a commentator commented the 'cat is finally out of the bag'.
II
(TIRUNELVELI: The special police team, led by Deputy Inspector General of Police, Tirunelveli Range, P Kannappan has arrested three persons in connection with the Tenkasi RSS office bomb blast case.
The investigations revealed that the blasts were planned to provoke a backlash between two groups of different and dominant communities in Tenkasi.Speaking to reporters at Tenkasi on Monday, Inspector General of Police, South Zone, Sanjeev Kumar said on January 24, there was a bomb blast at the RSS office and an auto, parked inside the new bus stand at Tenkasi, was destroyed.
Following this, special teams were formed to nab the accused. Investigations revealed that S Ravi Pandian (42), a cable TV operator, S Kumar (28), an auto driver, both from Tenkasi, and V Narayana Dharma (26) of Sencottai had planted 14 pipe bombs in the office of Ravi Pandian.
...Moreover, the bomb blast inside the new bus stand was planned to
divert the police investigation, said Sanjeev Kumar. ..
(3 arrested in Tenkasi bomb blast case, Tuesday February 5 2008 08:12
IST , Express News Service ( Newindian express))
It is for everyone to see that S Ravi Pandian (42), a cable TV operator, S Kumar (28), an auto driver, both from Tenkasi, and V Narayana Sharma (26) of Sencottai today represent the less reported phenomenon of Hindutva terrorism..For all practical purposes till 23 rd January they remained activists of Hindu Munnani - an affiliated organisation of RSS - engaged in what they seem to be a 'patriotic' work.
Today they are the new face of 'terrorism' unleashed by the Hindutva brigade.
But not only these three 'musketeers', one should add names of four more who were apprehended on 5 th February, identified as A. Balamurugan(20), S. Velmurugan (18), A Murugan (24), all hailing from Tenkasi and Maasaanam (20) of Shencottai. They have been arrested for assisting S. Pandian in making bombs and detonating them at the RSS office and town's new bus stand. According to 'The Hindu' ( 6 Feb 2008) the police even recovered bombs and detonators from them.
Looking at the hierarchial nature of the Sangh Parivar outfits, these
blasts would not have been triggered without the knowledge of its
top brass in Tamilnadu.
Thanks to the painstaking efforts engaged in by the Mr Kannappan, DIG Tirunelveli range, who did not fell prey to the usual stigmatisation and terrorisation of the religious minorities, and after thorough investigations into the incident (24 th January 2008) which involved bomb blasts at RSS office in Tenkasi and another one at the bus stand apprehended the culprits.
It is now learnt that the Sangh Parivar organisations which fared miserably during the last elections were keen that Tenkasi does a 'Coimbtore' and they are able to get few sympathy votes. It may be told that this is the 10 th anniversary of the Coimbtore blasts which had seen deaths of innocents.
A report
filed by M.H. Jawahirullah( www.twocircles.net) :
According to Sanjeev Kumar, IG, South Zone, the bomb blast inside
the new bus stand was planned to divert the police investigation.
DIG of Police Kannappan said the trio tested the capacity of the bombs
at Papanasam before executing the plan. Since the bombs contained
substances like ammonium nitrate, electric detonators, batteries and
timer devices, the explosion was possible within 30 to 40 seconds,
said Kannappan.The Investigation is still going on. The Police said
14 pipe bombs were assembled and the operations began from July last
year.
There are reports that the Tirunelveli Police have indicated that the explosives used in Tenkasi are similar those used in the Makkah Masjid blast at Hyderabad. It is incumbent that in the light of the revelations in the Tenkasi blasts , the CBI should reinvestigate the Makkah Masjid Blasts and other Blasts which took place in different parts of the country.
III
Lest anyone think that Tenkasi is an exception in the otherwise 'smooth' record of Hindutva brigade, one needs to know how a very similar attempt was made by their counterparts in Vidarbha, Maharashtra to provoke communal tension.
Of course instead of throwing pipe bombs at their own office, this time they delivered detonators in 'gift packets' to hapless traders belonging to Muslim community. The developments in Vardha, Maharashtra bear witness to this point.
October 15, 2007. Syed Yusuf Syed Mahmood, owner of ‘New Diamond Sale’ situated in Sarafa Line, Kale Chowk, Wardha would love to obliterate this date from his memory forever.
It was day after Eid and the time was 2 P.M.-2.30 P.M. As part of his usual routine he had gone out for lunch. And his friend Shaikh Hussain Shaikh Lukman was sitting at the counter. A young boy brownish in colour, wearing a full sleeve check shirt, reached the shop and made enquiries about Yusuf. On learning that Yusuf was not there he handed over a box with a Videocon cover to the sales girl which had a gift sticker pasted on it “ To Yusuf from Raj”.
After his
return to the shop at about 4 p.m. his friend handed over the ‘gift’
packet to him. One could say that it was sheer coincidence that he
grew suspicious after opening the packet which contained a box of
Videocon CD player inside and promptly called the police. A close
examination of the packet revealed that it contained detonators. A
Panchnama was duly conducted. Yusuf and his friends heaved a sigh
of relief that a tragedy was averted because of their presence of
mind.
Little they could realise that their happiness would be shortlived.
No sooner the Panchnama was over they got a message from Shaikh Hussain,
who runs a similar gift shop at Warud, Amravati, that Warud Police
Inspector Mr Rajesh came to visit his shop and asked him to wind it
up.
The very next day a similar incident was repeated at a shop ‘Sun Opticals’ (Socialist Chowk) owned by Idris Khan and Jaggu Anand. At around 3.40 p.m.when Idris Khan was at police station regarding the previous day’s incident he got a call from his shop reporting the presence of a similar gift box lying at his shop. The matter was immediately reported to the police. Police did not lose any time in rushing to the spot. A bomb disposal squad was called from Nagpur. Here also the ‘gift’ box had a simlar sticker pasted on it ‘From Raj’. Further examination revealed that the incident appeared to be a hoax as no incriminating material was found inside the box.
While it was clear from day one that all the three businessmen from minority community were law-abiding citizens, who had taken extra care to take the police into confidence, the local media saw to it that the whole incident was blown out of proportion. None from the media community deemed it even necessary to visit the actual spots but had no qualms in writing exaggerated and sensational versions of the whole affair. A newspaper went to the extent of declaring that 15 parcel bombs had been received at the shop of Idris Khan and police suspect the hand of SIMI.
On their part the Hindutva organisations went all out to pressurise the administration to deal firmly with the threat of ‘Islamic Terrorism’.
As of now
it transpires that the police have apprehended few Hindu youths belonging
to a local fanatic Hindutva organisation in connection with the delivery
of ‘gift’ packets laden with detonators.
It is a different matter that neither there is any official word from
the police over these arrests nor the media wants to convey to its
readers the real story. The media, which had written spicey-juicy
stories about the emergence of SIMI in the area and - ‘with
its nerve centre in Akola’ which had reportedly ‘started
functioing underground after gaining support of ISI of late’
( Times of India, 17 th October, Nagpur) has prefered to keep quiet
over these arrests.
It was noteworthy that civil liberty activists from Nagpur and Wardha decided to look into the matter and let facts speak for themselves. Apart from the ‘delivery of parcel bomb incident’ at Wardha the team also investigated house collapse at Vidhul (District Yavatmal) due to suspected bomb blast at the house of a hindu doctor and ‘police engineered riot at Achalpur’ ( District Amravati). It concluded that ‘..[m]edia has played a ‘particularly irresponsible role’ by attempting to ‘sensationalise the incidents and communalise the situation’ by reporting in a biased manner by quoting police sources only. The police on its part has not issued any ‘denials to these biased reports’ and helped on their part to ‘communalise the situation’ and has not tried to ‘diffuse the charged atmosphere. . ( For details of investigation , see ‘Report on the Communal Flare Up in Vidarbha’ , The Milli Gazette, 16-30 Nov 2007)
IV
Definitely neither the pipe bomb attack in Tenkasi nor the bomb scare incident at Wardha are the only incidents of its kind. One can cite incidents after incidents where the involvement of RSS, Shiv Sena or one of their affiliated organisations can be clearly demonstrated in acts which are considered ‘terrorists actions’ in todays parlance. It is a different matter that ‘Islamic Terrorists’ or ‘Maoists’ seem to be the usual whipping boys for the media or the intelligence people.
Leave editorial comment, how many journos even reported Digvijay Singh’s
communique wherein he talked of recovery of bombs and other explosive
material from the houses of RSS sympathisers from Shyampur, Sihore
and the consequent spurt in communal violence in and around Narsinghpur
(M.P.). According to the report ‘Sangh Sends Swords and Knifes’
Bhaskar, Hindi Daily ( 19 July 2007) :
General Secretary of Congress Party Mr Digvijay Singh has attacked Chief Minister Shivraj Singh Chauhan and RSS about recovery of arms in Shyampur District Sihore. While releasing a letter to the press which he has written to the Chief Minister Mr Singh categorically stated that members of RSS themselves are engaged in sending swords and knifes to instigate communal violence. The two miscreants from Shyampur who were found to be in possession of arms and were duly apprehended belong to RSS only. The letter specifically mentions that since the accused belong to RSS the chief minister would not take any action in this matter. You are under pressure from RSS also. Mentioning his earlier letter Mr Singh said that Mangilal and Phool Singh were arrested for delivering 24 swords and four knifes at Satyanarayan Bhati’s house on 16 th March. These two persons belong to RSS. Within a few days of the recovery of the arms, minorities in Narsinhgarh and Talen (Rajgarh) came under attack and five people from both the sides lost lives.
The Congress leader mentioned a letter written by Sihore S.P. which says that despite attempts by the police the two accused have refused to divulge the information about the source of these arms.
Or, how many mediapersonnel went to enquire into the manner in which Hindutva goons led by Bajrang Dal activists attacked a church and killed a pastor, as reported in a section of the media.
New Delhi
: Hindutva goons murdered a pastor and burnt a church at Mandwa village
under Kodenar police station of Jagdalpur district in Chhatisgarh
in the night of 20 November. The village has 60 Christian families
who are members of a Pentecoastal church. According to information
reaching the All India Christian Council in Delhi, in the night of
20 November, Bajrang Dal activists came in a jeep and surrounded the
Church with the help of some villagers. Pastor Sudroo, Ramlal, Sonadhar
Kashyap and Jugal Kashyap were tied with ropes and severely beaten
and the pastor was reported murdered by the fanatics
( Pastor Killed, Church Set On Fire by Hindutva goons, The Milli Gazette,
1-15 December 2007)
Or, for that matter how many even know that Nanded in Maharashtra witnessed deaths of four Hindutva activists in separate incidents ( April 2006 and February 2007) while ‘making bombs’ or ‘storing explosive materials’. And the narco tests of the accused in these cases revealed the modus operandi adopted by them in earlier incidents when Muslims were attacked at the time of prayers in Parbhani, Jalna and other places.
And to top it all, the expose by Tehelka in the Gujarat genocide of 2002 found that the ‘VHP and the Bajrang Dal had transformed themselves into terror outfits that manufactured and distributed bombs, rocket launchers and firearms in large quantities after the Godhra incident. This weaponry was then handed over to murderous mobs across Gujarat’ to be used against hapless Muslim population.
Haresh Bhatt, who was a leader of the Bajrang Dal and became a MLA from Godhra, admitted before the camera that ‘bombs were made at a firecracker factory he owned’ He describes ‘how they assembled country-made explosives, including rocket launchers. These were then distributed to murderous mobs in Ahmedabad’ The sting operation also revealed ‘ In 2002, despite curfew in Ahmedabad, swords wee brought in from Punjab and country made pistols from UP, Bihar and MP’. Dhawal Patel of the VHP used dynamite in his quarries in Sabarkantha and RDX based powder to make bombs.
Babu Bajrangi, an accused in the Naroda Patiya massacre, then a senior leader of the Vishwa Hindu Parishad is reported to have said on camera how they killed innocent Muslims in one such ‘operation’
‘They were clinging to each other in the pit. Then we threw oil and burning tyres and killed them.’
V
To conclude, the point one would like to emphasise that whether it is possible to link Tenkasi with Vardha or Nanded with Ahmedabad or for that matter Sihore or in our own atomised world view or not ?
Perhaps it is high time to revisit the phenomenon of terrorism in post-independent India and have a dispassionate look at stigmatisation of particular communities.
It would be possible to ask ourselves then what could be said to be the first act of terrorism in independent India ?
Everybody would agree that killing of Mahatma Gandhi by a Hindu fanatic Nathuram Godse constitutes the first terrorist act in independent India. Godse, a Maharashtrian Brahmin, was associated with Hindu Mahasabha at the time of Mahatma’s assasination and had his initial forays in the world of politics with the RSS. The world at large knows how the Hindu fanatics had planned the murder of the Mahatma and how the likes of Savarkar and Golwalkar were held responsible for creating the ambience of hate which culminated in the gruesome act.
If somebody poses before you another simple query relating to similar episodes in the sixty plus year trajectory of independent India - then what would be your response. Perhaps you would like to add the death of Indira Gandhi - killed by her Sikh bodyguards , killing of Rajeev Gandhi - who fell to a suicide attack by a Tamil Hindu woman, or for that matter demolition of the 500 year old Babri mosque by the marauders of the RSS-VHP-BJP-Shiv Sena. If one follows the debate further you would like to underline the 1984 riots ( actually genocide of Sikhs mainly perpetrated by Hindu lumpen elements instigated by the then ruling Congress Party), emergence of Khalistani terrorists movement or the five year old Gujarat genocide executed with military precision by the RSS and its affiliated organisations.
Compare all these major episodes in the history of Independent india - which encompassed many a terrorist acts within them - with the mental image which conjures up in your mind when one listens to any terrorist act in any part of the country. Does it have any resembelance with the image of a member of the majority community or one of those minority communities ? You would agree that the mental image has features specific to one of the religious minorities in our country.
Question naturally arises why is it that despite their participation in many a gruesome incidents, the role played by them in instigating riots ( as noted by many a commissions of enquiry) or there admission before camera about the planning which went in making a genocide happen (courtesy Tehelka sting operation) the Hindu fanatic who doubles up as a terrorist has not become a part of our social common sense. (To reemphasise one needs to underline that one is not being soft towards the likes of Lashkar-e-Toiba or Jaish-e-Mohammad, their activities are definitely condemnable but how is that every terrorist act in any part of the country is attributed to them and equally dangerours other outfits belonging to the majority community are allowed to go scotfree.)
Perhaps there is no simple answer to this query. One will have to dwelve deep into our past, take a dispassionate look at the anti-colonial struggle and also the tragic phase of partition riots. Simultaneously we will have to discern the threads of our present, understand for ourselves the role of different actors as well as the role of ideologies to reach any tentative understanding. It is for everyone to see that in a multireligious, multilingual country like ours the complexities of the situation are itself immense. We find ourselves in a situation where while ‘communalism’ of the majority community could be construed as ‘nationalism’, every assertion by the minority community on genuine demands tends to be seen with a ‘communal’ colour. And it follows from this that ‘terrorism’ unleashed by the majoritarians is easily disguised under the bursting of ‘pent up anger’ against the minorities.
