State
Department Memo:
'16 Words' Were False
By Jason Leopold
19 April, 2006
Countercurrents.org
Sixteen
days before President Bush's January 28, 2003, State of the Union address
in which he said that the US learned from British intelligence that
Iraq had attempted to acquire uranium from Africa - an explosive claim
that helped pave the way to war - the State Department told the CIA
that the intelligence the uranium claims were based upon were forgeries,
according to a newly declassified State Department memo.
The revelation of the warning
from the closely guarded State Department memo is the first piece of
hard evidence and the strongest to date that the Bush administration
manipulated and ignored intelligence information in their zeal to win
public support for invading Iraq.
On January 12, 2003, the
State Department's Bureau of Intelligence and Research (INR) "expressed
concerns to the CIA that the documents pertaining to the Iraq-Niger
deal were forgeries," the memo dated July 7, 2003, says.
Moreover, the memo says
that the State Department's doubts about the veracity of the uranium
claims may have been expressed to the intelligence community even earlier.
Those concerns, according
to the memo, are the reasons that former Secretary of State Colin Powell
refused to cite the uranium claims when he appeared before the United
Nations in February 5, 2003, - one week after Bush's State of the Union
address - to try and win support for a possible strike against Iraq.
"After considerable
back and forth between the CIA, the (State) Department, the IAEA (International
Atomic Energy Association), and the British, Secretary Powell's briefing
to the U.N. Security Council did not mention attempted Iraqi procurement
of uranium due to CIA concerns raised during the coordination regarding
the veracity of the information on the alleged Iraq-Niger agreement,"
the memo further states.
Iraq's interest in the yellowcake
caught the attention of Mohamed ElBaradei, the head of the International
Atomic Energy Association. ElBaradei had read a copy of the National
Intelligence Estimate and had personally contacted the State Department
and the National Security Council in hopes of obtaining evidence so
his agency could look into it.
ElBaradei sent a letter
to the White House and the National Security Council (NSC) in December
2002, warning senior officials he thought the documents were forgeries
and should not be cited by the administration as evidence that Iraq
was actively trying to obtain WMDs.
ElBaradei said he never
received a written response to his letter, despite repeated follow-up
calls he made to the White House, the NSC and the State Department.
Vice President Dick Cheney,
who made the rounds on the cable news shows that month, tried to discredit
ElBaradei's conclusion that the documents were forged.
"I think Mr. ElBaradei
frankly is wrong," Cheney said. "[The IAEA] has consistently
underestimated or missed what it was Saddam Hussein was doing. I don't
have any reason to believe they're any more valid this time than they've
been in the past."
As it turns out, ElBaradei
was correct, the declassified State Department memo now shows.
Monday's declassified State
Department memo was obtained over the weekend by The New York Sun under
a Freedom of Information Act request the newspaper filed last July.
The Sun's story Monday morning, however, did not say anything about
the State Department's warnings more than a week before Bush's State
of the Union address about the bogus Niger documents.
The memo was drafted by
Carl Ford Jr., the former head of the State Department's Bureau of Intelligence
and Research, in response to questions posed in June 2003 by I. Lewis
"Scooter" Libby, Vice President Dick Cheney's former chief
of staff, about a February 2002 fact-finding trip to Niger that former
Ambassador Joseph Wilson undertook to investigate the uranium claims
on behalf of the CIA.
It was Wilson's criticism
in mid-2003 of President Bush's use of the 16 words in his State of
the Union address and Wilson's subsequent allegations that the White
House knowingly twisted pre-war Iraq intelligence that led to the leak
of his wife's undercover CIA status.
Libby was indicted on five
counts of lying to federal investigators, perjury and obstruction of
justice about how he found out about Plame Wilson and whether he told
anyone in the media that she worked for the CIA.
The memo had originally
been drafted in June in response to Libby's questions about Wilson.
But after Wilson wrote an op-ed in the New York Times July 6, 2003,
in which he disclosed that he had personally investigated the Niger
uranium claims and found that they were false, Powell requested further
information from his aides. Ford went back and retrieved the June memo,
re-dated it July 7, 2003, and sent it to Powell's deputy, Richard Armitage.
The Sun reported that the
memo contained no direct reference to Plame Wilson's CIA status being
marked as "secret" despite the fact that the word "secret"
is clearly marked on every page of the INR memo.
The memo does not say that
the State Department alerted the White House on January 12, 2003, about
the bogus uranium claims.
But the memo's author, Carl
Ford, said in a previous interview that he has no doubt the State Department's
reservations about the Niger intelligence made its way to President
Bush, Vice President Cheney, and Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld.
One high-ranking State Department
official said that when the department's analysts briefed Colin Powell
about the Niger forgeries Powell met with former Director of the CIA
George Tenet and shared that information with him.
Tenet then told Vice President
Dick Cheney and then-National Security Adviser Condoleeza Rice and her
former deputy, Stephen Hadley, that the uranium claims were "dubious,"
according to current and former State Department and CIA officials who
have direct knowledge of what Tenet discussed with the White House at
the time.
The White House has long
maintained that they were never briefed about the State Department's
or the CIA's concerns related to the Niger uranium claims.
"I refuse to believe
that the findings of a four-star general and an envoy the CIA sent to
Niger to personally investigate the accuracy of the intelligence, as
well as our own research at the State Department, never got into the
hands of President Bush or Vice President Cheney. I don't buy it,"
said a high-ranking State Department official. "Saying that Iraq
sought uranium from Niger was all it took, as far as I'm concerned,
to convince the House to support the war. The American people too. I
believe removing Saddam Hussein was right and just. But the intelligence
that was used to state the case wasn't."
A spokeswoman for Tenet
said Monday that the former head of the CIA wouldn't comment on the
newly declassified document but promised that Tenet would tell the "full
story" about how the infamous 16 words wound up in Bush's State
of the Union address in Tenet's book, "At the Center of the Storm,"
expected to be published in late October.
Many career State Department
officials interviewed Monday said they were upset that the so-called
"16 words" made their way into the State of the Union address
and they are pleased that the INR memo has been declassified so as to
prove that their colleagues sounded early warnings about the dubious
Niger intelligence.
A State Department official
who has direct knowledge of the now declassified INR memo said when
the request came from Cheney's office for a report on Wilson's Niger
trip it was an opportunity to put in writing a document that would remind
the White House that it had been warned about the Niger claims early
on.
Many other State Department
officials believed that the existence of a memo that would, in essence,
disagree with the White House's own assessment on Niger would eventually
hurt the administration.
"This was the very
first time there was written evidence - not notes, but a request for
a report - from the State Department that documented why the Niger intel
was bullshit," said one retired State Department official.
"It was the only thing
in writing, and it had a certain value because it didn't come from the
IAEA. It came from State. It scared the heck out of a lot of people
because it proved that this guy Wilson's story was credible. I don't
think anybody wanted the media to know that the State Department disagreed
with the intelligence used by the White House. That's why Wilson had
to be shut down."
© 2006 Jason Leopold