The City
Where The Dead Are
Left Lying On The Streets
By Andrew Buncombe
in New Orleans
06 September 2005
The
Independent
In
a makeshift grave on the streets of New Orleans lies the body of Vera
Smith. She was an ordinary woman who, like thousands of her neighbours,
died because she was poor. Abandoned to her fate as the waters rose
around her, Vera's tragedy symbolises the great divide in America today.
However Vera Smith
may have lived her life, one thing was certain. In death, she had no
dignity. Killed in the chaotic aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, her body
lay under a tarpaulin at the junction of Magazine Street and Jackson
Avenue for five full days. Not her friends, her grieving husband, not
her neighbours could persuade the authorities to take her corpse away.
Finally, disgusted
by the way she had been abandoned - and concerned, too, about the health
implications of advancing decomposition - her friends buried her in
a makeshift grave. A local man fashioned a simple cross, and on top
of the soil that was shovelled over her body he placed a white plastic
sheet and wrote "Here Lies Vera. God Help Us."
The overwhelming
majority of the people who died or suffered in this disaster were, like
Vera, the poor - that segment of American society that so often appears
to be overlooked or deliberately ignored. These were the people unable
to evacuate, who had nowhere else to go or else no means of getting
there. These were the people who simply did not have the resources to
get a body taken to the morgue.
As the floodwaters
are pumped out of New Orleans' streets, rescue workers are bracing themselves
for further grisly discoveries and a death toll that will evenually
reach tens of thousands.
With the authorities
overwhelmed by the effort to find and rescue the living, they have been
forced to abandon the dead where they lie or, more often, where they
float. Vera, aged 65, was apparently killed by a hit-and-run driver
as New Orleans descended into chaos and anarchy the day after the storm
struck. Nothing better underlines the breakdown in the civic ability
to respond to this disaster than those police officers who shrugged
their shoulders helplessly when they were asked to remove Vera's body.
"She had gone
out to the shop to get something. We knew it was going to close. We
did not want to run out of anything," Vera's husband, Max Keene,
59, told The Independent yesterday, standing outside the couple's humble
rented home in the neighbourhood known as Irish Channel. "I did
not know what had happened to her. A guy came round to say she was lying
by the side of the road with a piece of cardboard over her. It was me
that went and put the tarp over her."
He added: "I
spoke to the police and asked them to take her away but they just told
me to get the hell out of there. It was dark and they were clearing
the streets."
Max and Vera were
not married in the formal sense but they had been together for 25 years.
They had met when she was working as a waitress in a bar and he was
working off-shore for one of the many oil companies that operate in
the Gulf of Mexico.
There was nothing
particular that struck Max about Vera, he recalled, but he liked her
sense of fun, her spirit. She liked clothes and shoes and shopping and
- like many people in this city - sometimes she liked a drink. She also
liked books and every Sunday she went to the local Catholic church,
St Mary's Assumption. Smith was her name from her first marriage; she
was originally from Mexico.
"She was married,
her old man left her. I had a different girlfriend then, she left me.
It was the right time. We just got together. Every now and then it happens
that way," said Mr Keene, tears in the corners of his eyes. "We
used to lie in bed. I'd drink bourbon, she'd read books."
Who knows how many
other stories there are like Vera's; how many other bodies lie scattered
across this besieged city? Local officials refuse to predict a total
but one thing is certain, the city is littered with abandoned corpses.
They are left in the street, in buildings, in the backs of trucks wrapped
in sheets with a name tag attached. One woman's body was discovered
sitting upright in a chair at the back of a dental surgery. The rescue
workers have had to leave them and instead concentrate on those who
are alive.
Harold Brandt, a
doctor from Baton Rouge who has been assisting rescue crews as they
search the still flooded areas of the city for survivors, said the biggest
concerns was the number of bodies that may be discovered in attics."One
of the things with Hurricane Betsy [in 1965] was that people climbed
into their attics to avoid the rising water and then they had no way
to escape and they drowned. Now, veterans of hurricanes will always
put an axe in their attic."
Vera, of course,
was not killed by the hurricane - as Max Keene stresses. The couple
had survived the storm and, knowing they would face days with out electricity
or water - or any assistance from the authorities, Vera was on her way
to the local store for supplies when she was knocked down.
Patrick McCarthy,
a retired electrician, was one those who helped bury her. "If you
need a metaphor for failure, this is as good as it gets," he said.
"Everybody should be buried. [This is] an insult to our humanity."
However Vera Smith
may have lived her life, one thing was certain. In death, she had no
dignity. Killed in the chaotic aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, her body
lay under a tarpaulin at the junction of Magazine Street and Jackson
Avenue for five full days. Not her friends, her grieving husband, not
her neighbours could persuade the authorities to take her corpse away.
Finally, disgusted
by the way she had been abandoned - and concerned, too, about the health
implications of advancing decomposition - her friends buried her in
a makeshift grave. A local man fashioned a simple cross, and on top
of the soil that was shovelled over her body he placed a white plastic
sheet and wrote "Here Lies Vera. God Help Us."
The overwhelming
majority of the people who died or suffered in this disaster were, like
Vera, the poor - that segment of American society that so often appears
to be overlooked or deliberately ignored. These were the people unable
to evacuate, who had nowhere else to go or else no means of getting
there. These were the people who simply did not have the resources to
get a body taken to the morgue.
As the floodwaters
are pumped out of New Orleans' streets, rescue workers are bracing themselves
for further grisly discoveries and a death toll that will evenually
reach tens of thousands.
With the authorities
overwhelmed by the effort to find and rescue the living, they have been
forced to abandon the dead where they lie or, more often, where they
float. Vera, aged 65, was apparently killed by a hit-and-run driver
as New Orleans descended into chaos and anarchy the day after the storm
struck. Nothing better underlines the breakdown in the civic ability
to respond to this disaster than those police officers who shrugged
their shoulders helplessly when they were asked to remove Vera's body.
"She had gone
out to the shop to get something. We knew it was going to close. We
did not want to run out of anything," Vera's husband, Max Keene,
59, told The Independent yesterday, standing outside the couple's humble
rented home in the neighbourhood known as Irish Channel. "I did
not know what had happened to her. A guy came round to say she was lying
by the side of the road with a piece of cardboard over her. It was me
that went and put the tarp over her."
He added: "I
spoke to the police and asked them to take her away but they just told
me to get the hell out of there. It was dark and they were clearing
the streets."
Max and Vera were not married in the formal sense but they had been
together for 25 years. They had met when she was working as a waitress
in a bar and he was working off-shore for one of the many oil companies
that operate in the Gulf of Mexico.
There was nothing
particular that struck Max about Vera, he recalled, but he liked her
sense of fun, her spirit. She liked clothes and shoes and shopping and
- like many people in this city - sometimes she liked a drink. She also
liked books and every Sunday she went to the local Catholic church,
St Mary's Assumption. Smith was her name from her first marriage; she
was originally from Mexico.
"She was married,
her old man left her. I had a different girlfriend then, she left me.
It was the right time. We just got together. Every now and then it happens
that way," said Mr Keene, tears in the corners of his eyes. "We
used to lie in bed. I'd drink bourbon, she'd read books."
Who knows how many
other stories there are like Vera's; how many other bodies lie scattered
across this besieged city? Local officials refuse to predict a total
but one thing is certain, the city is littered with abandoned corpses.
They are left in the street, in buildings, in the backs of trucks wrapped
in sheets with a name tag attached. One woman's body was discovered
sitting upright in a chair at the back of a dental surgery. The rescue
workers have had to leave them and instead concentrate on those who
are alive.
Harold Brandt, a
doctor from Baton Rouge who has been assisting rescue crews as they
search the still flooded areas of the city for survivors, said the biggest
concerns was the number of bodies that may be discovered in attics."One
of the things with Hurricane Betsy [in 1965] was that people climbed
into their attics to avoid the rising water and then they had no way
to escape and they drowned. Now, veterans of hurricanes will always
put an axe in their attic."
Vera, of course,
was not killed by the hurricane - as Max Keene stresses. The couple
had survived the storm and, knowing they would face days with out electricity
or water - or any assistance from the authorities, Vera was on her way
to the local store for supplies when she was knocked down.
Patrick McCarthy,
a retired electrician, was one those who helped bury her. "If you
need a metaphor for failure, this is as good as it gets," he said.
"Everybody should be buried. [This is] an insult to our humanity."
© 2005 Independent
News & Media (UK) Ltd.