SAHMAT Report continued....
TARGETING WITH PRECISION
The one sided nature of the violence mentioned above was further exemplified
by the fact that the Hindu dominated areas surrounding the completely
devastated Muslim settlements remained untouched and were back into
normalcy within a few days. This selective violence, executed with remarkable
precision has indubitably helped in preventing a consolidation of opinion
within the majority community against the violence, if not gaining its
tacit support. The message of the violence was quite clearly conveyed--if
you are a Hindu you need not fear at all; this is not directed against
you as long as you do not side with the Muslims.
Thousands of shops and business establishments belonging to the Muslims
were ransacked and destroyed, often being selectively chosen from within
a cluster of shops. A visit to Shalimar Complex where nearly 40 out
of 50 odd shops belonged to Muslims disclosed how those were selectively
targeted, looted and burnt on the day of the VHP sponsored bandh. A
doctor couple whose chamber and pathological laboratory were situated
in the complex was robbed of all their belongings including expensive
medical equipment. The rioters came in large numbers and broke open
the shutters and simply carried away every thing within the shops before
burning them. Goods worth lakhs of Rupees were looted in this complex
itself. Shops owned by Hindus were left untouched.
Eyewitness accounts suggest
that the Revenue Minister in Gujarat government (former Home Minister)
Haren Pandya, and another Minister Ashok Bhatt were personally present
during the looting and arson, and actually led the mobs.
Hotels and restaurants owned by Muslims also came in for this selective
attack. Given the history of communal riots these restaurants were already
running under 'Hindu' names like Tulsi, Abhilasha etc. to conceal their
Muslim ownership. However, the information regarding every such business
establishment was there with the rioters. It has been alleged that a
local Gujarati daily Sandesh carried the names of all such Muslim owned
establishments in Ahmedabad which were running under 'Hindu' names,
about a month earlier.
The worst such instance was
the burning of the Hans Inn where inmates, mostly people from outside
Gujarat, were not even allowed to come out and 14 of them were burnt
alive inside the building. It is claimed that a Punjab Police officer
and constable who had come for an investigation were among the victims.
The name of Haren Pandya was repeatedly mentioned regarding this case
also.
SOCIO-ECONOMIC WAR AGAINST MUSLIMS
This selective targeting of business establishments is only a part of
the greater economic war the VHP proposes to wage against the Muslims
in Gujarat. A leaflet circulated by the VHP (Annexure 1) calls for a
total economic boycott of the Muslims in order to 'throttle' them, 'break
their backbone' so that 'it will be difficult for them to live in any
corner of this country' . It is precisely this vision which was being
implemented when Muslim establishments were being selectively looted
and destroyed.
This communal project also becomes clear from the fact that Muslims
from all sections of the population, from slum dwellers to businessmen
and white collar professionals to senior government bureaucrats were
targeted during the attacks. A visit to the posh locality of Paldi revealed
how even the upper middle class sections of the Muslim community were
targeted. The Delite and Tarana Apartments were completely gutted and
the belongings of the Muslim flat owners of these multi-storied apartments
looted. The residents included the Director of Industries, Gujarat government
and a senior employee of the Gujarat University.
Frantic phone calls to Ministers,
ruling party politicians and even to politicians in Delhi could not
prevent the total destruction of the apartments by a 5000 strong mob
which broke open into the flats and ransacked them. The residents were
able to avoid the fate of Ehsan Jafri (former Congress MP who was burnt
alive in Gulmarg Society ) by silently hiding in the terrace of the
building and not raising their voice even when the mobs went on a rampage
inside their homes. They could not conceal their deep hurt while recollecting
that many people from their neighbouring apartments whom they had known
and lived together with for several years, not only cheered the rioters
during the long operation but some of them actually participated in
it.
All these eerie experiences point towards a tremendous communalization
of society that has taken place in Ahmedabad and other places of Gujarat.
Hatred towards the Muslim minority has been systematically inculcated
in such a manner that violence of barbaric proportions against them
is not only widely condoned but also even enjoyed by certain sections
of the Hindu communities.
The press statement issued
by noted historian Prof. K.N. Panikkar on 9th March after his visit
to Ahmedabad, is thus significant: " What happened in Ahmedabad
and other towns and villages in Gujarat is not a spontaneous action.
The methods used for destruction of life and property presupposes a
fairly well organised preparation. It is clear that many incidents during
these last ten days could not have happened without such a preparation.
In a way it indicates a long-term process of communalisation and brutalisation
of society. A major issue which society has to face is the influence
of brutality, which appears to have conquered the minds of men. This
is the result of the systematic and long-term atrocities of communal
organisations and heightened by the irrational and emotional coercion
of the people by both the VHP and the RSS."
It only needs to be added that even middle class women were found participating
in the looting of jewelry and garment stores in the elite CG Road area
of Ahmedabad during the VHP bandh, which also shows the extent comunalization
of Gujarati society.
The collusion of the state was absolute. Firstly, the state administration
and the police failed to protect the lives and properties of Muslim
citizens, even when several people complaining about mobs attacking
their homes or shops contacted them. Many of them were told that they
would have to fend for themselves on that day. Secondly, in many cases
BJP, VHP and Bajrang Dal leaders including Ministers and local corporators,
actually led the mobs and supervised the killings and destruction. And
finally, the Administration is now busy in ensuring a massive cover
up.
While the role of the national print and electronic media has been applauded
widely for its coverage of the violence and exposure of government's
negligence, the role of the local Gujarati media has hardly attracted
adequate attention. Like in the past, the vernacular Gujarati press
played an extremely biased role with the Sandesh directly contributing
to incitement and provocation for violence. The Gujarat Samachar, the
most widely circulated vernacular daily, was cynically referred to by
many in having played a 'moderate' (communal) role this time compared
to its earlier record.
Both the State and the local media have helped the VHP and RSS in organizing
the violence against the minorities. Had it not been their collusion,
neither would the rioters have had such precise information about the
residences and business establishments of the Muslims, nor would the
RSS-VHP have been able to mobilise the enormous machinery that was deployed
to play havoc in Ahmedabad during this period. Thus describing the violence
in Ahmedabad as a State sponsored ethnic cleansing would appear to be
appropriate.
CONDITION OF RELIEF CAMPS
The most glaring evidence of the bias of the Modi Government in Gujarat
can be found in the condition of the 20 odd relief camps for Muslim
refugees, which are being run in Ahmedabad alone. It is estimated that
more than 70,000 Muslims have been rendered homeless and are staying
in these camps spread across the city. The camps include bigger ones
at Shah-e-Alam Dargah and Aman Chowk housing 8-9,000 refugees and smaller
ones like in Sundaramnagar and Saraspur Pathrewali masjid [Madhav Mill
complex] having 3-4,000 people. A visit to these places confirmed allegations
regarding total negligence and apathy of the government towards the
innocent people who have been rendered refugees in their own land.
Before the all-party MP's delegation visited Ahmedabad, some camps have
been set up with government support housing Hindu refugees. While there
are Hindu victims of the violence, their numbers and extents of loss
are disproportionately lower than the Muslims and certainly not proportionate
to what the government and VHP are seeking to establish. However, the
communal attitude gets clearly exposed by the fact that while a Deputy
Collector is in charge of the government run relief camp at Kankaria
for the Hindu victims, the larger camps run for the Muslims have virtually
no official support. No senior official or politician had visited the
larger Muslim camps till as late as 11th March. In one of the smaller
Muslim camps, two Deputy Mamladars had been deputed a day before the
Chief Minister visited it on 6th March. The all party MP' s delegation
was taken to only a handful of the smaller Muslim camps along with the
Hindu camps to give a completely distorted picture of the violence that
took place.
The Muslim camps are being run mainly through the support of community
leaders and organisations, NGOs, missionaries and other private sources
including some political organisations have also made significant donations.
The rations, which the government has started giving very late, are
grossly inadequate. In fact the Shah-e-Alam camp managers alleged that
the weekly ration being given by the government is actually not sufficient
for a single day's consumption. Thousands of homeless people are having
to stay under shamianas in the absence of any provision for their shelter.
Blankets or clothes are not available. There is hardly any medical help
in most places and even child births are taking place in the camps without
proper medical facilities. The less said about sanitation the better.
In Shah-e-Alam there is only one mobile toilet with 4 chambers for nearly
9,000 people! This is particularly disturbing because the Ahmedabad
Municipal Corporation is Congress[I]-led and controlled.
With the government almost totally abdicating all responsibilities of
providing relief, the issue of rehabilitation is shrouded in uncertainty.
There has been no official recording of the Muslim refuges so far let
alone any significant effort to lodge their complaints/FIRs by setting
up police camps. Some complained about money being charged by the local
police to register complaints. Moreover, no security has been provided
to protect these camps from future attacks. The helpless, insecure and
traumatized Muslim masses have been left to fend for themselves. According
to a report, near one such Muslim camp in Vatwa , audio cassettes with
cries and howls of 'maro maro' are played at night on loudspeakers regularly,
to further terrorize the refugees there who are yet to recover from
the trauma of the violence on 1st March.
It seems that the government is deliberately pushing this enormous number
of Muslim population to the margins of survival. Due to the extremely
unsanitary conditions there are genuine fears of outbreaks of epidemics
in these camps. Moreover, since almost all the refugees have lost their
ration cards and the government is showing no interest in identifying
them, there is the dangerous possibility of a huge number of people
losing their basic citizenship rights. The insecure residents of the
camps have no place to go back since entire settlements have been completely
demolished. Unless immediate relief and proper rehabilitation is ensured
for the Muslim refugees, a great human tragedy of much larger proportions
to what has already taken place, is bound to happen.
With the Ayodhya issue coming to dominate the centre stage of national
politics, the plight of Muslims in Gujarat has not received the attention
it merits. The media as well as the Opposition need to highlight the
issue of relief and rehabilitation of the victims of the violence in
Ahmedabad and other places immediately. Given the character of the State
as well as the Central Government, it is only a concerted action on
the part of the secular and democratic sections of society and the polity
that a bigger human tragedy can be prevented.
DESTRUCTION OF HISTORICAL MONUMENTS
AND PLACES OF WORSHIP
Along with the butchering
of human lives, there has been widespread destruction of masjids and
dargahs. Rough estimates suggest 20 odd mosques being demolished in
Ahmedabad alone. As has been mentioned earlier, the major attacks were
organized on 1st March and the pattern seems to suggest targeting of
mosques in all parts of city, during the Friday prayers. In most of
the places, Hindu idols were placed on the site of the mosques after
demolishing them, thus converting them into temples a la VHP style.
In many cases, liquor was consumed within the mosques and madrassas,
and holy books burnt within madrassas . The small Hindu temple within
the Muslim locality of Sundaramnagar which remained unharmed while its
neighbouring mosque and madrassa were burnt and destroyed, stood in
sharp contrast to the vandalism of the VHP rioters.
However, these attacks on the mosques should not be seen only in terms
of being acts of provocation meant to incite the Muslim minority by
hurting religious sentiments. They were also accompanied by attacks
on historical monuments. The famous 500-year-old masjid in Isanpur,
which was an ASI monument, was destroyed with the help of cranes and
bulldozers. The famous Urdu Poet Wali Gujarati's dargah was also razed
to the ground at Shahibag in Ahmedabad. While a hanuman shrine was built
over its debris initially, all that was removed overnight and the plot
was metalled and merged with the adjoining road. No authority claimed
any knowledge about the entire episode. It is worth noting here that
the Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation, which is responsible for the maintenance
of all these structures, and for the building of roads, is run by the
Congress with a near two-thirds majority.
VHP's campaign to rename Ahmedabad as Karnavati is well known. In accordance
with that revivalist project there has been over the past, a proliferation
of roadside temples coming up overnight all over the city. Now taking
advantage of the situation the same project seems to have been furthered
by demolishing monuments and mosques which stood as symbols of the composite
cultural heritage and of course served as deterrents to the RSS-VHP'
s distortion of the history of Ahmedabad.
CONCLUSION
The attitude among the affected Muslims in Ahmedabad today is of sheer
despondency. The myths created by the VHP-RSS regarding Muslims being
heavily armed by external forces stand shattered in the face of absolutely
no resistance, armed or otherwise, on the latter' s part. However, the
fear and communal stereotypes, which has been instilled in the minds
of many Hindus through years of propaganda, continues to make them apprehend
violent retaliation. Reports say that even trucks carrying relief materials
were stopped from moving into relief camps on the grounds that they
might be carrying arms for Muslims.
Had it not been for the Army's intervention, many more innocent Muslims
would have been killed. Apart from the Army, no other institution of
the state remains to be credible in the eyes of the affected people.
Peace, security and justice seem to be a far cry for them.
The politically motivated statements by Chief Minister Modi, likening
the communal conflagration to a Newtonian reaction, have only deepened
their alienation. Union Home Minister L.K. Advani sought to defend the
Modi government's role in Parliament. Perhaps he would also be in the
know of the allegations within his own Parliamentary constituency against
the Gujarat Home Minister Gobardhanbhai Zapadia's brother distributing
arms and leading riotous mobs.
It will take generations for the victims to recover from such a pointed
and vicious communal onslaught.
It is of immediate importance
to bring the perpetrators to book and prosecute them under the criminal
laws of the country. The Government of Gujarat and its chief executive
are widely believed to be responsible for this carnage. Therefore, the
CG Shah enquiry instituted by them has little credibility.
A high level and time bound
judicial enquiry by a sitting Supreme Court/High Court judge should
be instituted to look into the entire episode and bring the guilty to
justice. The Union government must direct the Gujarat government to
set up such an enquiry, and to provide it all necessary assistance expeditiously,
so that it can arrive at its findings at the earliest. In the meanwhile,
a CBI enquiry into the role of the police, with those with prima facie
cases against them being suspended/transferred, may also be instituted.
The role of the local Gujarati press must be examined by the Press Council,
and where the laws of the land have been transgressed exemplary action
must be taken, so that communal fires are not fanned again.
Proper and adequate relief measures should be given to all victims and
no effort should be spared for their rehabilitation. Prompt and adequate
compensation is a must. In view of the perceived partisanship of the
Modi government, the local corporation and trusted civil society organisations
must be involved. In a number of cases, Muslims would not like to return
to their earlier localities. State as well as civil society efforts
are required to rebuild trust and ties of friendship and good neighbourliness.
But where these efforts fail, alternative sites will have to be found,
and housing built. Long term steps should be taken to ensure that Gujarati
society returns to its secular roots and to the tradition of its most
revered son Mahatma Gandhi.
......
A TRANSLATION OF THE CIRCULAR LETTER IN GUJARATI DISTRIBUTED IN THE
STREETS OF AHMEDABAD
by Viswa Hindu Parishat
SATYAM SHIVAM SUNDARAM
JAI SHRI RAM
WAKE UP! ARISE! THINK! ENFORCE!
SAVE THE COUNTRY! SAVE THE
RELGION!
Economic boycott is the only
solution! The anti-national elements use the money earned from the Hindus
to destroy us! They buy arms! They molest our sisters and daughters!
The way to break the back-bone of these elements is: An economic non-cooperation
movement.
Let us resolve -
1. From now on I will not
buy anything from a Muslim shopkeeper!
2. I will not sell anything from my shop to such elements!
3. Neither shall I use the hotels of these anti-nationals, nor their
garages!
4. 1 shall give my vehicles
only to Hindu garages! From a needle to gold, I
shall not buy anything made by Muslims, neither shall we sell them things
made by us!
5. Boycott wholeheartedly
films in which Muslim hero-heroines act! Throw out films produced by
these anti-nationals!
6. Never work in offices
of Muslims! Do not hire them!
7. Do not let them buy offices
in our business premises, nor sell or hire out
houses to them in our housing societies, colonies or communities.
8. 1 shall certainly vote,
but only for him who will protect the Hindu nation.
9. 1 shall be alert to ensure
that our sisters-daughters do not fall into the
'love-trap' of Muslim boys at school-college-workplace.
IO. I shall not receive any
education or training from a Muslim teacher.
Such a strict economic boycott
will throttle these elements! It will break their back-bone! Then it
will be difficult for them to live in any comer of this country. Friends,
begin this economic boycott from today! Then no Muslim will raise his
head before us! Did you read this leaflet? Then make ten photocopies
of it, and distribute it to our brothers. The curse of Hanumanji be
on him who does not implement this, and distribute it to others! The
curse of Ramchandraji also be on him! Jai Shriram!
A true Hindu patriot
Safdar Hashmi Memorial Trust
(SAHMAT) is a cultural organisation based in Delhi