Nasiruddin Haider Khan
is a Gujarati?
What kind of a question is this? Gujarati is anyone who lives in Gujarat.
That's what I assumed whenever Narendra Modi spoke of 5 crore Gujarati's
pride (asmita). I thought, he meant all people living in Gujarat. But
I always had little bit of doubt, has Modi had a change of heart? How
is it that he speaking about every citizens of Gujarat. Then I thought,
It is not proper to doubt his every statement and safe to assume that
at least on the record he is talking about all the people living in
I was wrong, even on the record Mr. Modi was speaking from his heart.
On a recent trip to Gujarat, I took an auto-rickshaw from Judges Bunglow
road to go to Sabarmati Ashram. It was a journey of 25-30 minutes and
as usual I started talking to the driver. My usual questions- who are
you? Where are you from? How is Mr. Modi and what will happen in the
Gujarati," he said.
I can guess from your language."
The he said
his name was Raju and said, "all Gujaratis are with Mr. Modi."
didn't you understand?" and he laughs.
gave me the answer what he meant by "them," but I wanted to
hear from his mouth. Then he said, "Muslims are not with BJP."
are you talking about?, Muslims are not Gujaratis. Hindus are Gujaratis.
How can they be Gujarati?"
Aha, I came
to my senses, when Chief Minister Mr. Narendra Bhai Modi talks about
Gujaratis, it includes everyone except "them."
lower middle class auto-rickshaw driver helped me understand the rhetoric
of Mr. Modi.
While I was
still in the midst of this confusion of who is a Gujarati and who is
not, I recalled an interview by a Gujarati Lord Meghnad Desai. An economist
and social activist Lord Desai said in the interview that for last one
and a half decade Sangh Parivar have been actively promoting this thinking
among the Hindus that only they are Gujarati and others are "them."
This new thinking have been accepted by the middle class, this is the
same class that is active in the online world and you can see effect
of this thinking in blogs and comments on various sites. This middle
class serves as the ideological courier of the Parivar. Now you can
easily understand that whenever there is a mention of 5 crore Gujaratis,
who is being left out.
Now, I am again in dilemma, what will happen to the father of Dakkani
Urdu, Wali Gujarati. Wali Gujarati who is buried in the soil of Gujarat,
is not a Gujarati (whose grave was demolished in 2002 and a road built
over it)? What will you call Rajab Ali who along with his friend Vasant
Rao gave up his life to maintain communal harmony in Ahmedabad. What
about Ehsan Jafri, who was burned in the fire of Gujarat and spread
in the air of Gujarat.
we call Ghulam Mohammad Sheikh, who put Gujarat on the painting map
of the world. What about Bandukwala? What name will be given to garba
music of Ismail Darbar? Zaheer Khan, Irfan Pathan, Yusuf Pathan, Saira,
Rashida, Niazben where will they fit? Are they Gujarati or just "them"
in Modi's Gujarat?
If you want
to read this piece and other Gujarat special in Hindi, please visit
Share Your Insights
it! And spread the word!
Here is a unique chance to help this article to be read by thousands
of people more. You just Digg it, and it will appear in the home page
of Digg.com and thousands more will read it. Digg is nothing but an
vote, the article with most votes will go to the top of the page. So,
as you read just give a digg and help thousands more to read this article.