Marx
Was Right, Absolutely Right
By
Vidyadhar Date
08 December,
2007
Countercurrents.org
The
violence against the peasants in Singur and Nandigram in the past few
months has raised serious questions about the nature of governance by
the West Bengal government led by the Communist party of India (Marxist).
However,
the fault lies not with Marxist philosophy. Actually, Marx was on the
ball , as David Harvey, the eminent Marxist geographer, author and thinker,
pointed out in Mumbai on December 6.
He was not
referring to the developments in West Bengal but about Marxism in general.He
speaking at the conclusion of the fifth international conference of
Critical Geography at the Tata Institute of Social Sciences. A large
number of participating academics and activists, many of them left-wing,
were concerned over the developments in West Bengal.
Dr Harvey
knows what he is talking about as he is teaching Marx's Capital since
1970 and this may be the last year of doing so as his students have
now decided to put his teaching on the internet for free.
He began
with an anecdote. Two yers ago he was on a panel to evaluate the design
for a new city , 200 km south of Seoul in South Korea. During the discussion
two members of the panel, an architect and a landscape designer, went
on arguing endlessly whether the pattern of the city should be of a
grid or should it be circular.
Then Dr
Harvey intervened and said there were much more important issues to
be looked at. What kind of technology, transport, social relations,
labour processes, daily life of people, the production system, the city's
relation to Nature all this will have to be taken into consideration.
Only then a city can be properly planned. Since the city was to locate
various ministries, it would become dull and this will have to be prevented
by taking other
measures.
The architect
and landscape designer were quite impressed and asked Dr Harvey where
he got all these good ideas from ? The reply stumped them. The ideas
came from a footnote in Marx's Capital, chapter 15, volume 1.
The foot
note says that `technology discloses man's mode of dealing with nature,
the process of production by which he sustains his life and thereby
also lays bare the mode of formation of his social relations and of
the mental conceptions that flow from them.'
In the chapter
on machinery Marx shows how capitalist society grows. Marx was also
on the ball in anticipating the tremendous concentration of wealth in
the hands of a few under the current neoliberalism.
The problem
with capitalism is that it will collapse if it does not invest huge
surplus and people do not use their credit cards and go on buying things.
That is why there is such a huge construction boom in cities all over
the world. It is not just that slums are mushrooming as Mike Davis has
shown in his book The Planet of Slums.
Dr Harvey
said blaming imperialism, the World Bank and IMF will not take us far.
People have to check the elites in their own countries. The bank and
IMF are not currently as powerful as before.
The financial
markets are in a deep crisis and the people at the helm themelves do
not know what to do as the situation is very volatile. But the trgedy
is that if the crisis worsens, it will hit the poor the most so some
Leftists are not right when hope the system will crash.
In reply to a question he said capitalism had some positive aspects,
there was a better recognition of individual rights, gay rights and
the rights of the handicapped in the United States.
But the
environmental and other consequences of capitalism were so serious that
there was no way the system can sustain itself socially or politically.
A severe
critique of claims of India as a shining success story of economic reforms
was made by Prof Utsa Patnaik of the Jawaharlal Nehru university in
her inaugural lecture.
Citing from
her extensive research she showed how the per capita food consumption
in India was much lower than during world war II and there was widespread
malnutrition not only among children and women but also among men.
The policy
of diverting millions of acres of land under food crops for export crops
and crops to make biodiesel had created severe problems of food security.
This was accompanied by reducing the purchasing power of the masses
and through mass unemployment.
The situation
in Nandigram was explained to the delegates by conference convener Prof
Swapna Banerjee Guha who hails from West Bengal. She said it was important
to analyse the disturbing developments and the role of Left Front government
in a Parliamentary democracy.
Leave
A Comment
&
Share Your Insights
Comment
Policy
Digg
it! And spread the word!
Here is a unique chance to help this article to be read by thousands
of people more. You just Digg it, and it will appear in the home page
of Digg.com and thousands more will read it. Digg is nothing but an
vote, the article with most votes will go to the top of the page. So,
as you read just give a digg and help thousands more to read this article.