Educating
Pakistan
By Niranjan Ramakrishnan
07 November, 2007
Countercurrents.org
My late father, a government
official, liked to say half-in-jest that it might be cheaper to pay
the bureaucracy to stay home; it would save the country a good deal
of money and damage. This is as good a prescription for a Congress now
getting ready to confirm Michael Mukasey as Attorney General. His qualification,
according to Charles Schumer, one of his Democratic backers, who holds
this truth to self-sufficient: Michael Mukasey is not Alberto Gonzales.
Well, that is right up there with the proof of fitness proffered by
another AG, "I have not been indicted" (Edwin Meese). According
to Schumer, Mukasey would bring back confidence and elan to the Justice
Department. How? By couching Richard Nixon's "when the president
does it, then it is legal" in loftier language? This is rather
like saying that Cheney would be an improvement on Bush.
Gonzales was part-goon, part-dufus, revealing an intellectual dimension
rivaled only by his master's while also mirroring the latter's other
quality -- an ethereal insouciance untethered to any record of competence.
Mukasey is not Alberto Gonzales. Ergo, according to Schumer and Feinstein,
he is the man for the job. Why, in this country of 300 million and home
to a lopsided number of lawyers, we cannot look for someone who will
uphold the Constitution unequivocally, is one more mystery of our times.
As happens frequently the larger issue has been crowded out by a smaller
one. For all its repugnance, waterboarding is only a symptom of a government
serenely contemptuous of the law. What if Mukasey had allowed that waterboarding
was torture? Would it change his non-stance on the violation of the
FISA? Does he think warrantless wiretapping is illegal? Does he think
detention without trial is ok? How about abolition of habeas corpus?
What about the War Powers Act?
One would think the Senators would have held him accountable by his
answers on all such questions. But how could our politicians, who themselves
do not think these questions are vital (or they would be stopping all
government business until every one of these usurpations and violations
was reversed) think to grill a nominee in this manner? Are they not
themselves are busy giving away the store, passing retroactive justification
for Bush and Cheney's merry devastations of the law?
One shudders when one reflects that with so many Senators, a disavowal
of waterboarding by Mukasey would have clinched their support. It is
an indication of how completely apolitical is our political class, which
can comprehend nothing but commerce. Politics is about power. Congressional
authority has been disemboweled during the Bush term; neither Republicans
nor Democrats have even shown resentment, let alone fight.
General Pervez Musharraf, imposing an emergency on Pakistan last week
and suspending the constitution, regretted that he had to do so out
of necessity, because other branches of government were playing an adversarial
role. In the US, per our Constitution, the Congress is designed to act
as a check on the executive. Instead, it now views itself as no more
than an smooth enabler. Pakistan's protesting opposition has been put
under house arrest. Ours is busy colluding with the usurpers.
Give us time, give us time, said Musharraf in his speech, appealing
to the West; we are still learning, our democracy is not yet as evolved
as yours. Musharraf is right -- Pakistan is still a child in these matters.
Clearly his friend and financier in the White House has not let him
in on the big secret -- in an 'evolved' democracy, you can get all this
power without declaring an emergency!
Niranjan Ramakrishnan is a writer. He can be reached
at [email protected].
Leave
A Comment
&
Share Your Insights
Comment
Policy
Digg
it! And spread the word!
Here is a unique chance to help this article to be read by thousands
of people more. You just Digg it, and it will appear in the home page
of Digg.com and thousands more will read it. Digg is nothing but an
vote, the article with most votes will go to the top of the page. So,
as you read just give a digg and help thousands more to read this article.