"Bring
'Em On?"
By Stan Goff
16 July, 2003
In 1970, when I arrived at
my unit, Company A, 4th Battalion/503rd Infantry, 173rd Airborne Brigade,
in what was then the Republic of Vietnam, I was charged up for a fight.
I believed that if we didn't stop the communists in Vietnam, we'd eventually
be fighting this global conspiracy in the streets of Hot Springs, Arkansas.
I'd been toughened by Basic Training, Infantry Training and Parachute
Training, taught how to use my weapons and equipment, and I was confident
in my ability to vanquish the skinny unter-menschen. So I was dismayed
when one of my new colleagues--a veteran who'd been there ten months--told
me, "We are losing this war."
Not only that, he said, if
I wanted to survive for my one year there, I had to understand one very
basic thing. All Vietnamese were the enemy, and for us, the grunts on
the ground, this was a race war. Within one month, it was apparent that
everything he told me was true, and that every reason that was being
given to the American public for the war was not true.
We had a battalion commander
whom I never saw. He would fly over in a Loach helicopter and give cavalier
instructions to do things like "take your unit 13 kilometers to
the north." In the Central Highlands, 13 kilometers is something
we had to hack out with machetes, in 98-degree heat, carrying sometimes
90 pounds over our body weights, over steep, slippery terrain. The battalion
commander never picked up a machete as far as we knew, and after these
directives he'd fly back to an air-conditioned headquarters in LZ English
near Bong-son. We often fantasized together about shooting his helicopter
down as a way of relieving our deep resentment against this faceless,
starched and spit-shined despot.
Yesterday, when I read that
US Commander-in-Chief George W. Bush, in a moment of blustering arm-chair
machismo, sent a message to the 'non-existent' Iraqi guerrillas to "bring
'em on," the first image in my mind was a 20-year-old soldier in
an ever-more-fragile marriage, who'd been away from home for 8 months.
He participated in the initial invasion, and was told he'd be home for
the 4th of July. He has a newfound familiarity with corpses, and everything
he thought he knew last year is now under revision. He is sent out into
the streets of Fallujah (or some other city), where he has already been
shot at once or twice with automatic weapons or an RPG, and his nerves
are raw. He is wearing Kevlar and ceramic body armor, a Kevlar helmet,
a load carrying harness with ammunition, grenades, flex-cuffs, first-aid
gear, water, and assorted other paraphernalia. His weapon weighs seven
pounds, ten with a double magazine. His boots are bloused, and his long-sleeve
shirt is buttoned at the wrist. It is between 100-110 degrees Fahrenheit
at midday. He's been eating MRE's three times a day, when he has an
appetite in this heat, and even his urine is beginning to smell like
preservatives. Mosquitoes and sand flies plague him in the evenings,
and he probably pulls a guard shift every night, never sleeping straight
through. He and his comrades are beginning to get on each others' nerves.
The rumors of 'going-home, not-going-home' are keeping him on an emotional
roller coaster. Directives from on high are contradictory, confusing,
and often stupid. The whole population seems hostile to him and he is
developing a deep animosity for Iraq and all its people--as well as
for official narratives.
This is the lad who will
hear from someone that George W. Bush, dressed in a suit with a belly
full of rich food, just hurled a manly taunt from a 72-degree studio
at the 'non-existent' Iraqi resistance.
This de facto president is
finally seeing his poll numbers fall. Even chauvinist paranoia has a
half-life, it seems. His legitimacy is being eroded as even the mainstream
press has discovered now that the pretext for the war was a lie. It
may have been control over the oil, after all. Anti-war forces are regrouping
as an anti-occupation movement. Now, exercising his one true talent--blundering--George
W. Bush has begun the improbable process of alienating the very troops
upon whom he depends to carry out the neo-con ambition of restructuring
the world by arms.
Somewhere in Balad, or Fallujah,
or Baghdad, there is a soldier telling a new replacement, "We are
losing this war."
Stan Goff is the author of
"Hideous Dream: A Soldier's Memoir of the US Invasion of Haiti"
(Soft Skull Press, 2000) and of the upcoming book "Full Spectrum
Disorder" (Soft Skull Press, 2003). He retired in 1996 from the
US Army, from 3rd Special Forces. He lives in Raleigh.
He can be reached at: [email protected]
From a soldier's father
"My son is in the U.S.Army
and currently stationed in Baghdad. I hear from him every three or four
days. He is like most of the young men and women who went to fight over
there inasmuch as he was proud to go and achieve what President Bush
said was necessary. I have seen his attitude take a U-turn during the
last month. At first he was saying: "I wonder why we are not doing
this or that to help make life better for our soldiers?" Then he
started to wonder why we were not doing more to help the Iraqi people
who are suffering under terrible conditions. Not enough water or food,
no electricity most of the time, a terrible shortage of medical supplies
and medical staff, basically they are living like animals. Then he started
to worry about the safety of our troops in the area. He says they are
sitting ducks and easy targets for Iraqi people bent upon gaining revenge
for slain family members and by those who hold the U.S. responsible
for the terrible conditions they find themselves in. Yesterday he had
a different message altogether."
"Get us out of here
now! There is nothing we can do to pacify the Iraqi people except get
out of their country and allow them to restore order in whatever way
THEY wish."
And, allow me to give you
his remarks when he was informed of President Bush's brash remarks saying
"Bring them on." He said:
"Myself and every
last man in my unit are deeply offended that our President would make
such a statement inviting us to be attacked. President Bush has lost
the respect of every soldier I have spoken to because of his speaking
those irresponsible words. Those words spread like wild-fire amoung
the troops. We are here because he ordered us to be here and now for
him to make such a ridiculous statement inviting violence towards us
causes us to lose respect for him and his judgement. We are learning
that we never should have come here in the first place. Believe me Dad,
there is a completely different attitude now. The fact that the President
gave rich people a tax cut and didn't do anything for military families
is hurtful. Where there was once pride and satisfaction in defeating
an enemy there is now regret and shame. God Bless America.
Your loving Son, Donny