Sharmila: 'Iron Lady' Of Manipur
By Subhash Gatade
17 October, 2006
Yes, 'n' how many times can a man turn his head,
Pretending he just doesn't see ?
Sharmila.(Age 34). Does that name sound familiar?
Well, like most of us this
youngest daughter of Irom Nanda and Irom Sakhi Devi has many identities.
For sister Vijayanti or brother Singhajit she is their dearest sister
who had the 'never say die' spirit ingrained in her since childhood.
For some of her dear friends she is an Yoga enthusiast who at times
also dabbled in naturopathy. For litterateurs of Manipur, she is a budding
poetess who has written hundreds of poems but till date only one of
her collections 'Imadi Khongdai Setlaroi' has been published. And for
the vast majority of Manipuris, she is not Irom Sharmila Thanu rather
she is the 'Iron Lady of Manipur' who has challenged a callous and apathetic
government and its regime of draconian law with her unique struggle.
Interestingly, despite plethora
of TV channels and a boom in the print media, not many of us from 'mainland'
India would be able to tell what made this young girl from a lower middle
class family who could not even continue her education after 12 th,
a legend in her own lifetime.
It is difficult to believe
the saga of struggle of Irom Sharmila Thanu
In fact it will be nearly
six years that she would be on her hunger strike.She has remained without
solid food since then, demanding withdrawal from her state, of one of
the most draconian laws in the statue books called Armed Forces Special
Powers Act (AFSPA).
At present she is lodged
in AIIMS, New Delhi where she is being 'nasal fed' by a team of doctors.
Her reaching Delhi from the
environs of Jawaharlal Nehru Hospital, Manipur where she was kept in
judicial custody and was nasal fed was another saga of her glorious
struggle. Taking advantage of the release from custody after serving
a 'yearlong custody' at the hospital, her supporters literally smuggled
her out of Imphal to reach Delhi to turn her "regional" campaign
into a "national" one. Her first stop in Delhi was Rajghat,
where she laid a wreath at Mahatma Gandhi's samadhi. Later she told
a journalist "I want to tell the people of India that if Mahatma
Gandhi were alive today, he would have launched a movement against the
Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act. My appeal to the citizens of the
country is to join the campaign against the army act," (The Telegraph,October
Ofcourse, the historic fast
launched at Malom was no planned affair. There was a firing by security
forces at Malom bus stand, which is nearly 15-16 kilometers from Imphal,
on 2 nd November 2000. It saw blood of ten innocents spilled on the
streets. Ofcourse it was not the first event of its kind, the streets
of Manipur had been witness to the killings of innocent
citizens umpteen times before.
Mother Irom Sakhi Devi had
no inkling of what was in store of her youngest daughter Sharmila.She
merely sought her mother's blessings to work for 'betterment of humanity'
and left. Sharmila straight away went to the very spot where the bloodbath
had occurred and started her fast unto death. Her demand was simple
to articulate but for the powers that be difficult to implement. She
demanded repeal of the draconian law. Initially for the residents of
Malom or adjoining areas it was difficult to fathom the idea of the
peaceful resistance put up by this young woman. For a handful of them
she was an object of ridicule also. And none of them had even imagined
that she would persist in her determination in such a way that there
would be uproar all over the state in support of her demand. By 21 st
November the administration was forced to give her a 'nasal feed' in
a hospital in Imphal.
The maximum sentence which
a court can give for 'trying to committ suicide is one year' and Sharmila
has endured many such turns in all these years. She is released after
this one year judicial detention and immediately rearrested and put
in the same ward. and the cycle continued . This year also the government
expected the same. Embarrassed police officials later admitted that
they had no inkling of the plan to "smuggle out" Chief minister
Okram Ibobi Singh pleaded
Irom Sharmila's legendary
struggle for human rights has become an important symbol of the resistance
of the Manipuri people who are fighting their present day suffering
at the hands of policy makers. This has meant 'excessive militarisation
of the region' and the 'promulgations of many a black laws like AFSPA
at the cost of the life and liberty of the people of this region.'
It is a sad commentary on
the state of affairs that the rest of the world came to know about Sharmila's
unique struggle only two and half years ago only. It was in the aftermath
of a militant struggle launched by Manipuri people demanding the abolition
of the Armed Forces Special Powers Act, 1958 and punishment to the Assam
Rifles people for killing Thangjam Manorama on 11 July 2004
This upsurge of the Manipuri
people was marked by the way in which women played a leading role in
furthering the movement. It was on 15 th July 2004 that around dozen
elderly and respectable Manipuri women marched to the area headquarters
of the Assam Rifles and stripped naked and waved a banner which read
as : "Indian Army Rape Us", "Indian Army Take Our Flesh".The
naked march of these women electrified the masses and within no time
the protests against the army reached new heights.
The conspiracy of silence
which had surrounded Iron Sharmila's solitary struggle can't be called
an exception. It is part of a general silence which surrounds developments
in northeast which for all practical purposes exists on the 'borders
of our consciousness'. A report brought out by a National Campaign Committee
agains militarisation and repeal of AFSPA had rightly observed a few
years back : 'Armed militancy, intercommunity killings, 'encounters'
with security personnel ... conversely, pretty girls and boys dancing
in traditional costume. The north east has always been a collage of
the most contradictory images, that only reflect how little is known
of the reality that lies behind them.'
There is no doubt that if
the atrocities at the hands of the security forces as are witnessed
in north east would have taken place in any part of 'mainland India'
then it would have become a cause for national uproar. But for all those
areas which are under Armed Forces Special Powers Act all such acts
by the the security people are 'covered under the infamous act' itself.
As the provisions of the infamous act make clear the security forces
have been given unlimted powers and even if they committ atrocities
( which is not exception but the rule) people have no right to approach
This 'draconian law' which
has generated tremendous anger in the minds of the people and is in
many ways worse than the infamous POTA empowers the security people
in many crucial areas.It empowers the government ( governor of the state,
or the administartor of the union territory, or the central government
) to declare any area a 'disturbed area' if it reaches a conclusion
that [t]he whole or any is in such a disturbed or dangerous condition
that the use of Armed Forces in aid of civil power is necessary,' the
concerned authority may 'declare the whole or such
part of such a state or union territory to be disturbed area.'
Section four delienates the
powers sanctioned to any commissioned officer, warrant officer, non-commissioned
officer,.in a disturbed area.
a) If in his opinion, it
is necessary for maintenance for public order to fire even to the extent
of causing death or otherwise use force against a person who is acting
in contravention of an order prohibiting the assembly of five or more
persons or the carrying of weapons or of things capable of being used
b) If in his opinion, it
is necessary to do so, then to destroy any arms dump or fortified position,
any shelter from which armed attacks are made or are 'likely to be made',
and any structure used as training camp for armed volunteers or as a
hide out for armed gangs or absconders.
c) arrest without warrant
any person who has committed a cognizable offence or against whom a
reasonable suspicion exists that he has committed or is likely to commit
a cognizable offence and to use whatever force is necessary to affect
d) to enter and search without
warrant any premises to make an arrest or to recover any person wrongfully
confined or to recover any arms, ammunition, explosive substance or
suspected stolen property.
Section 5 makes it mandatory
for the army to hand over a person arrested under the act to the nearest
police station with least possible delay.
Section 6 lays down that
prosecution, suit or other legal proceedings can be instituted against
a person acting under the act, only after getting previous sanction
of the central government. ( Ref: The Illusion of Justice : Supreme
Court Judgement on the AFSPA, May 1998, People's Union for Democratic
The existence of this law
on the statue books has thus meant disallowing the people the right
to protest, the right to legal redress or right of any lawful democratic
activity. Ordinary people who want to live a life of peace and tranquility,
can thus easily be framed as 'terrorists' and 'suspects' linking them
to banned organisations. Democratic rights activists who merely document
the excesses by the Army or an end to army rule have also been picked
up, tortured and killed.The continuation of this law since last 48 years
has effiectively meant that under a formal democratic set up 38 million
people residing in north east are forced to live under an undeclared
emergency or defacto military rule.
Brigadier Sailo who served
in the army for 31 years, in a letter written nearly 30 years ago to
Ms Indira Gandhi, the then prime minister of India, said," The
feelings of the entire villages and population of Mizoram are now totally
alienated by the denial of all decencies of human rights and any picture
which may have been painted to you to the contrary, is totally false."
(Quoted in Where 'Peacekeepers' Have Declared War - :Report on violations
of democratic rights by security forces and the impact of the AFSPA
on civilian life in the seven states of North East - National Campaign
Committee against Militarisation and Repeal of AFSPA, 2000, Delhi).It
can be said without any iota of doubt that what Brigadier Sailo said
about Mizoram can be applied to the whole of north east today.
One cannot say with certainty
what will happen next.
Hunger strike by Irom Sharmila
continues unabated. If earlier the venue was the dingy rooms of the
Jawaharlal Nehru Hospital in Imphal, today she lies in a similar position
in a private ward in AIIMS, New Delhi where she is forcibly fed liquids
through a nose-pipe. It was only last month that BBC (Tuesday, 19 September
2006, 09:46 GMT 10:46 UK) had carried a report on this marathon fast
wherein it had mentioned the deteriorating condition of her health :
"Doctors say her fasting is now having a direct impact on her body's
normal functioning - her bones have become brittle and she has developed
other medical problems too. "
As far as the repeal of the
black law is concerned, things seem to be going nowhere. It is being
said that the Justice Jeevan Reddy committee appointed by the Prime
Minister in 2004 in the aftermath of the militant protests in Manipur
has recommended repeal of the legislation AFPSA itself. According to
reports in a section of the media, the 146 report submitted by the Jeevan
Reddy committee talks about "The act is too sketchy, too bald and
quite inadequate in several particulars". According to the report
"the act, for whatever reason, has become a symbol of oppression,
an object of hate and an instrument of discrimination and high-handedness'(
The Hindu, October 8, 2006)
According to few analysts
a careful reading of the report also creates an impression that the
Jeevan Reddy panel merely wanted the prerogatives of the armed forces
transferred wholesale onto another law, the Unlawful Activities (Prevention)
Act, 1967. If this holds true then we will have a situation where the
dreaded black law AFPSA which is basically applicable to North East
and Jammu-Kashmir may be scrapped forthwith while the revised ULP act
1967 which incorporates all the necessary provisions of AFPSA would
come into force. It would mean the whole of India may come under the
ambit of a substiute of AFPSA.
In any case this cannot be
tolerated at any cost. All those people who yearn for a life of peace,
justice and progress for the broad masses of people would have to come
together to defeat the machinations of the powers that be.
While talking to the BBC
correspondent Irom Sharmila had mentioned "My fast is on behalf
of the people of Manipur. This is not a personal battle - this is symbolic.
It is a symbol of truth, love and peace,".
It is worth mentioning that
while Sharmila is waging this unequal battle against the Indian state,
many of her dear and near ones have stood solidly behind her. We are
also told that not only her brother lost a government job, because he
preferred to remain on her side always but the family had also to go
bankrupt since it gathered lot of loans during this period.
But none of the sacrifices
can match what Irom Sakhi, Sharmila's 75 year old mother has endured
all these years. She has never met her daughter since she blessed her
on the momentous day when she undertook her fast. Irom Sakhi, with tears
in her eyes told a correspondent : It is just possible that my getting
emotional on seeing her may weaken her resolve. And I do not want that
my daughter lose in this battle, which is for the betterment of humanity.
¦Subhash Gatade ,
H 4, Rohini Sector 15,Delhi
110085, Ph : 011-27872835 email : firstname.lastname@example.org
Share Your Insights