Madhany:
Victim Of State Terror
By B.F Firos
28 April, 2007
Countercurrents.org
The case of Abdul Nasar Madhany’s
imprisonment for the last nine long years simply belies India’s
much-trumpeted democratic values and judicial system. He has been lodged
in the Coimbatore jail as a trial prisoner as one of the accused in
the Coimbatore bomb blast case without parole or bail. But the issue
goes unreported in the mainstream media and such a serious instance
of human rights violation unheard of in the post-independent India continues
to remain as a bloat on Indian’s democratic credentials.
Madhany, hailing from a village
in the Kollam district in Kerala, was basically an Islamic cleric (the
word Madhany denotes to a religious degree). It was in 1993 that he
founded People’s Democratic Party (PDP), an outfit consisting
of backward communities like Muslims and Dalits. For the first time
in the history of India, here was a man advocating “power to the
untouchable”.
Post-Babari demolition, Madhany’s
political party gained momentum in the context of reasons like the political
degradation of parties representing Muslims, like Indian Union Muslim
League (IUML), the rise of Hindutva forces and the sidelining of the
marginalised sections including Muslims and Dalits. His fiery and articulate
speeches on several burning issues annoyed the mainstream political
parties, especially IUML, a party claiming to espouse the cause of Muslims.
He intervened on issues like
the persecution of Muslims in places like Palakkad post-Babari demolition.
One of his targets was the then north DGP Raman Srivastava - whose open
call to his subordinates “I want the dead bodies of Muslim bastards”
ended up in the killing of an innocent 11-year-old girl in Palakkad
at the height of the post-Babari demolition riots. The many issues that
he took up were enough fodder for the extremist Hindutva forces to target
him. He lost one of his legs in a bomb attack by the RSS. And the culprits
of this crime are still at large.
The wide-held impression
that has been circulated in the mainstream parlance is that Madhany
is an accused in the Coimbatore bomb blast case that killed 59 persons
in 1997. But consider the following. Even after nine long years of interrogation
and grilling of 2760 witnesses, numerous cross examinations and filing
of chargesheet running into 2760 pages (weighing up 47 kilogram), neither
the Tamil Nadu police nor the prosecution has been able to prove his
connection to the Coimbatore bomb blast case. The prosecution has not
so far been able to produce even a single witness or a trace of evidence
against Madhany.
Looking back, one can find
that Madhany’s arrest was connected somehow to the now-infamous
Kozhikode ice-cream parlour sex racket case involving powerful IUML
leader and former Kerala Industries Minister P.K. Kunhalikutty.
It goes like this: Madhany,
in association with ex-Naxalite leaders K. Ajitha and K. Kunhikannan
decided to initiate a state-wide agitation against the ice-cream case.
On the very third day (31st March, 1998) Madhany is picked up by Kozhikode
Kasaba police on a charge of making provocative speech that took place
five years back. None asked why Madhany was not arrested during those
five years after the arrest warrant was issued in the case of making
the provocative speech.
Soon after arresting Madhany
on charges of making provocative speech, he was transferred to the Tamil
Nadu police in connection with the Coimbatore bomb blast case. It will
be interesting to enquire into on what grounds Madhany was linked to
the bomb blast case. The Tamil Nadu police wanted to grill Madhany as
they found that Basha, the key accused in the Coimbatore bomb blast
case, had a one-and-half minute’s conversation with someone in
the office of Muslim Review, a magazine ran by Madhany at that time.
The most intriguing factor is that in the very next issue of Muslim
Review an interview with Basha was published. In fact, the phone call
was made from the magazine’s office to Basha for arranging the
interview. There was no trace of evidence to suggest that it was Madhany
and Basha who had talked each other over the phone.
Today, even after nine years
of uninterrupted imprisonment, one will find it intriguing that this
handicapped man’s life and future hangs on that one-and-half minutes
phone call. The alacrity of the politician-official nexus to trap Madhany
was evident from the fact that the then Kasaba police Circle Inspector
had given a fake testimony in the court. In the testimony the CI managed
to obtain a statement purported to be made by Madhany saying he had
connections to the Coimbatore bomb blast case. But in the court the
testimony was summarily rejected as the signature of Madhany was found
fake. (And today, that police officer occupies a top position in the
police hierarchy.)
After some preliminary questioning,
TN police included Madhany as the 45th accused in the Coimbatore bomb
blast case. And even then the main charge was conspiracy in the bomb
blast case. Though many ‘evidences’ were raised, the prominent
among them was that one-and-half minute phone call.
And consequently, Madhany
underwent imprisonment in Salem and Coimbatore prisons for the first
four years. But no chargesheet was filed initially; and there was only
the FIR. When efforts were made to approach the Supreme Court for bail,
the bogey of Maintenance of Internal Securities Act (MISA) was imposed
as an additional charge, making the task of seeking bail/parole tough.
Today, nine years of imprisonment
has made Madhany a prisoner of so many ailments like cervical Spondylosis,
back pain, ulcer, and fierce diabetic. When he was arrested his weight
was 104 kg. Now his weight has been reduced to below 50 kg. And adding
to all these woes is the untold hardships owing to his broken artificial
leg, with which he has to perform all his daily chords.
Rules continue to be manipulated
in the case of Madhany. First of all, bail or parole has been a no-no
for him all these years. And looks like the jail manual has been “amended”
exclusively for him! Severe restrictions are in place for his relatives/friends
to visit him in jail, unheard of even in the case of hardcore criminals
charged with serious offences.
Whenever bail applications
were filed in the court citing his weak health and other humanitarian
grounds, the prosecution opposed it one several grounds. The prominent
among them were: If bail is given to him there are chances that he would
leave the country; he would influence the witnesses; the possibility
of he again committing these kinds of `crimes’ cannot be ruled
out; the law and order situation will be in danger if he is set free,
etc. Back in Kerala, he is a hot favorite of both the Right and Left
wings in their election campaigns. But no serious efforts were ever
taken for his release. When bail was sought for attending the funeral
of Madhany's grand mother a few years ago, the TN government refused
to grant it on the basis of a report given by the then Kerala Chief
Minister, saying that if he is released that will create law and order
problem in the state.
“These points have
no legality given that Madhany can’t even walk without the help
of crutches or outside help. He doesn’t have a passport to go
abroad. The argument that he would influence the witnesses has no basis,
given that all the witnesses in the case have already been grilled,”
says Adv. Ramkumar, Madhany’s counsel.
“Above all, prosecution
continues to give lots of counter affidavits in the trial court against
Madhany with the aim of obstructing the trial. The court never took
care of the above-mentioned arguments in favour of Madhany, despite
their veracity and validity, put forward by the Madhany’s counsels
at different occasions during the trail,” he says.
It may be noted here that
Sankaracharya, who is facing a similar kind of charges, was given bail
by the Supreme Court even before the trial. But Madhany continues to
be denied bail or parole, the prerogative of any Indian citizen.
The court took into account
only the version of the police and prosecution. In 2000 April, Judge
Thanikachalam denied Madhany bail on the pretext that he is part of
‘bomb culture’, saying his leg was lost in bomb attack.
He was also branded as a social evil because of the fact that there
are so many cases against him in Kerala!
Madhany’s counsels
are hopeful that the final verdict on him may be pronounced within two
or three months. In case he is found guilty, he may be punished for
a few years in jail. Then what about the jail term he has already undergone?
Can the courts give him back the nine years of jail term he underwent?
And what if he is found innocent?
Who’s really behind
prolonging the incarceration of Madhany? Is it a nexus between the rightwing
Hindutva forces and the officials? Or is it just a case of an effort
to silence him gone awry? Whatever may be the reasons, this gross injustice
being meted out to this individual is an affront to the values of justice
and freedom that we espouse day and night. Long live democracy!
Digg
it! And spread the word!
Here is a unique chance to help this article to be read by thousands
of people more. You just Digg it, and it will appear in the home page
of Digg.com and thousands more will read it. Digg is nothing but an
vote, the article with most votes will go to the top of the page. So,
as you read just give a digg and help thousands more to read this article.
Click
here to comment
on this article