Support Indy
Media

Popularise CC

Join News Letter

Read CC In Your
Own Language

CC Malayalam

Iraq

Peak Oil

Alternative Energy

Climate Change

US Imperialism

US Elections

Palestine

Latin America

Communalism

Gender/Feminism

Dalit

Globalisation

Humanrights

Economy

India-pakistan

Kashmir

Environment

Book Review

Gujarat Pogrom

WSF

Arts/Culture

India Elections

Archives

Links

Submission Policy

Contact Us

Subscribe To Our
News Letter

Name: E-mail:

 

Printer Friendly Version

An Olympic Triumph For China

By Kent Ewing

25 August, 2008
Asia Times Online

HONG KONG - This time, the handover went the other way.

In a rousing closing ceremony for the XXIX Olympiad on Sunday night - a grand and joyous party at Beijing's "Bird's Nest" National Stadium that seemed as much a celebration of China's rising star on the world stage as it was a capstone to 17 days of athletic achievement - the Olympic flag was passed to London Mayor Boris Johnson, whose city will host the 2012 Games.

Johnson has said he and his country are "not intimidated" by the magnificent scale and success of the Beijing Games, and the eight-minute handover performance featuring soccer icon footballer David Beckham, Led Zeppelin guitarist Jimmy Page and London-born pop singer Leona Lewis was promising enough.

Still, it will be hard to match this Olympic show, which opened and closed so masterfully under the direction of China's most renowned filmmaker Zhang Yimou. The venues built for the Games have provided state-of-the-art settings for brilliant athletes such as American swimmer Michael Phelps, Jamaican sprinter Usain Bolt and China's nonpareil group of divers and table tennis players; indeed, the National Stadium and the "Water Cube" National Aquatics Center stand as iconic monuments to these Games.

Hong Kong made its own proud contribution to the Olympics, receiving all-around rave reviews for its staging of the equestrian events.

In the end, Chinese athletes took full advantage of their status as hosts of these Games. China won more gold medals, 51, than any other country and, in bagging 100 medals overall, was second only to the United States in the total medal count. And while the world's best athletes were showcasing their talents in first-rate facilities, Chinese security forces kept terrorism at bay. Finally, even Beijing's notorious air pollution cleared, as Chinese officials had promised and the International Olympic Committee (IOC) had prayed, and blue skies prevailed.

By any standards, the Beijing Olympics was a triumph for China. Why, then, has there been so much carping about the Games in the Western media? For every story about the success of Chinese athletes or the grand vision and artistic prowess on display in the opening and closing ceremonies, it seems there is another one on the oppressive authoritarianism of the Chinese government or Beijing's broken promises on allowing protests and greater media freedom. Is all this so much sour grapes from Western powers frightened and jealous of China's increasing international clout?

Some critics have even likened the Beijing Olympics to the 1936 Games held in Berlin to legitimize Nazi rule of Germany. While such a comparison is maliciously wide of the mark, the flood of commentary on this summer's Games has once again served to illustrate the enormous perception gap between China and the West. For the Chinese, there is something potentially sinister in the stubborn refusal among China-bashers to recognize the tremendous progress the country has made - not just on economic issues but socially and politically as well.

There was, however, a dark side to these Games. It was mostly hidden and unseen, but that only made its presence more disturbing. At times, the Chinese security apparatus showed its true colors - for example, when police manhandled journalists trying to cover the rowdy crowds lining up to buy tickets prior to the opening of the Games, wrongly detaining a photographer working for Hong Kong's South China Morning Post. Two Japanese reporters were also beaten and detained in China's western Xinjiang autonomous region while covering an apparent terrorist attack on a remote police outpost that left 16 people dead. No doubt with the imminent opening of the Games in mind, local authorities apologized to the Japanese reporters and pledged to pay any medical bills that they incur.

For a true picture of China's still-woeful record on media freedom, go to the Foreign Correspondents' Club of China website. There are more than 300 complaints posted there since January 1, 2007, detailing official harassment of journalists who were simply trying to do their job. Such complaints continued into the Olympics when reporters at the Olympic press center discovered that their Internet access had been restricted.

And where were all the protestors, both foreign and domestic, at these Games? Given all the anti-China demonstrations overseas leading up to the Games - protests over everything from Beijing's crackdown in Tibet to its exportation of faulty, sometimes lethal products - there was once speculation that this summer's Olympics could be remembered as the "Protest Games". Over the last several years, thousands of "mass incidents" - the official euphemism for demonstrations, often violent, by aggrieved Chinese citizens - also fueled this speculation.

Following the lead of Sydney in 2000 and Athens in 2004, the Chinese even established official protest zones in three parks in Beijing. Once the Games actually began, however, there was scarcely a demonstrator to be seen. No applications for protests were approved, and the three parks have turned into recreation havens for the elderly and families with young children.

At least two elderly women were persona non grata in these parks, however. Neighbors Wu Dianyuan, 79, and Wang Xiuying, 77 - who applied for a protest permit because their homes in central Beijing were demolished seven years ago to help make way for the stunning Olympic infrastructure that is now the admiration of the world - have been sentenced to a year of re-education through labor for their efforts.

Grannies in labor camps? This news is not going to be well received in any part of the world and is certainly not the kind of image the Chinese leadership wanted to have associated with their grand coming-out party. Surely, it will be reversed - and the sooner, the better.

The few protests that did occur during the Olympics were directed by foreigners who had come to Beijing under the guise of sports fans, but those demonstrations were quickly snuffed out and their perpetrators detained. The reason there were not a lot more of them is now an open secret. Beijing was so stingy about granting visas ahead of the Games that many hotels in the capital were half empty while at the same time billions of television viewers tuned in to watch China's big moment in the sun. Indeed, the relative dearth of foreigners at these Games marks them as the least international in character in recent memory.

Aside from these complaints, Chinese leaders are also probably smarting over allegations of cheating (in gymnastics) and proof of fakery (in the otherwise flawless opening ceremony). But here, too, the perception gap looms large.

Some of China's gold-medal-winning female gymnasts do look awfully young, and state media had just a year ago reported the age of one of them, He Kexin, as 13. But that has all changed now. Birth certificates, passports and other documents show that all members of the team will be at least 16 years old this year, as required by Olympic rules. That ends the debate as far as Chinese Olympic officials are concerned, but an unsatisfied International Federation of Gymnasts has asked for further clarification and senior members of the IOC have also expressed doubt.

In the knock-out opening ceremony, the fireworks that began it all - those distinctive "footprints" in the sky leading to the National Stadium - turned out to be computer-generated. Then it was revealed that Lin Miaoke, the adorable nine-year-old girl who captivated the world with her performance of a song titled Ode to the Motherland, was actually lip-synching to the beautiful voice of seven-year-old Yang Peiyi, who had been judged too unattractive to be seen.

While the Lin Miaoke controversy stirred up some lively discussion in Internet chat rooms among China's growing band of Internet users, for the most part the use of such skillful artifice in the national interest is a no-brainer to the Chinese. To China's critics, however, these deceptions are reminders that the country is untrustworthy and not yet ready for the leading role it aspires to on the world stage.

In Western eyes, then, China's promises of greater honesty, tolerance and openness ring hollow as the Games end. For many Chinese, however, Beijing has done well to compromise but not capitulate to Western demands; such capitulation would be seen as not only humiliating but also destabilizing in a country still struggling to balance social equity with torrid economic growth.

As the blaze of fireworks, the extraordinary athletic achievements and the predictable controversies fade into memory, it is important to give Beijing its due. The Beijing Olympics has been a grand success and an important symbol of the progress China has made as a rising nation, progress that should be recognized, encouraged and applauded.

In comparative terms, China, despite its many flaws, has never been more free and open, and this ongoing but gradual process may - indeed, should - be accelerated by its hosting of the Games. We can only wait, hope and see.

Kent Ewing is a teacher and writer at Hong Kong International School. He can be reached at [email protected].

Copyright 2008 Asia Times Online

Leave A Comment
&
Share Your Insights

Comment Policy


 

Digg it! And spread the word!



Here is a unique chance to help this article to be read by thousands of people more. You just Digg it, and it will appear in the home page of Digg.com and thousands more will read it. Digg is nothing but an vote, the article with most votes will go to the top of the page. So, as you read just give a digg and help thousands more to read this article.



 

Feed Burner
URL

Support Indy
Media

 

Search Our Archive

 



Our Site

Web