Japan
Infiltrates The Middle East
By Shirzad Azad
26 May , 2007
Fpif.org
Japanese
Prime Minister Shinzo Abe’s recent Middle East tour was the second
trip to the region by a Japanese prime minister in less than 16 months.
By visiting five Arab nations in a single trip and pursuing a wide range
of economic, political and strategic objectives for his country, Abe
opened a new chapter in Japan’s Middle East policy.
Tokyo’s desire for
a stable supply of energy has run up against its other foreign policy
objectives. While Tokyo was a big supporter of the Bush administration’s
invasion of Iraq, it is uncomfortable with Washington’s hard-line
approach toward Iran. After all, Iran is Japan’s third-largest
supplier of crude oil. As it angles to become a more moderating influence
in Middle East politics, Japan may find itself butting heads more often
with the United States.
Thirsty Japan
Topping Abe’s agenda on his recent trip was seeking new ways of
securing energy supplies for Japan. Tokyo has long been dependant on
the Middle East for most of its oil imports, and Japan’s increased
demand for natural gas is likely to deepen its dependence on that turbulent
and volatile region. Japan is the world’s largest importer of
natural gas, and roughly 90% of its oil needs come from the Middle East.
Japan is worried that the emergence of newly energy-hungry economies
of Asia, especially China and India, may challenge its long-term access
to crude oil and natural gas in the countries surrounding the Persian
Gulf area.
Japan has many good reasons
to worry about the supply of its economy’s lifeblood. It may face
serious consequences from the new energy rush and the prospect of reaching
peak global oil production, particularly in the face of rising competitors
in Asia. For example, China alongside India and Iran form the triangle
of Asian ancient civilization. China has a long history of trading with
the Middle East that goes back many centuries to the Silk Road era.
Many Chinese citizens are now working in oil-producing Arab countries.
And China’s rising political power, stemming from its economic
growth, has tempted autocratic rulers of Middle East countries to develop
their relationship with Beijing, hoping to balance the West’s
long-term interference in the region.
Japanese companies have lost
part of their Middle East markets to Chinese goods. For instance, according
to current trends, China will likely replace both the United States
and Japan as Saudi Arabia’s top trading partner by the end of
this decade. Other countries in the region may also follow the suit,
in the same way that Iran replaced Japan with China as the biggest importer
of its oil.
Like China, India has a considerable
labor force working in the Middle East, and the influence of its cultural
affinity and soft power in the region outweighs other East Asian countries.
After all, the symbol of India, the Taj Mahal built in 1631 in memory
of Iranian princess Mumtaz Mahal, is but one example of the historical
connections between the Indians and Middle East nations.
Such concerns have forced
Japan to reconsider its Middle East strategy and broaden its involvement
in the region to include non-oil investments. Abe went to the region,
for instance, with a large delegation of 175 businessmen led by Fujio
Mitarai, head of the Japan Business Federation. This symbolic gesture
indicated just how eager Japan is to forge multi-layered ties with the
region that go far beyond energy deals and economic necessities. Trade
officials in Tokyo have also voiced support for a free trade agreement
(FTA) with six oil-producing countries of the Gulf Cooperation Council
(GCC) in the Middle East, starting in 2008 with Saudi Arabia and the
United Arab Emirates. Japan’s Asian arch-rivals, China and India,
have already started negotiations on FTAs with the GCC countries, while
the Japanese only launched such negotiations in September 2006 with
a focus on agriculture and goods.
Japan has developed other
tactics. For instance, Abe’s visit to Saudi Arabia, followed by
Trade Minister Akira Amari two days after, included an offer to King
Abdullah that Saudi Arabia’s state-run oil company use part of
Japan’s oil-stockpiling facility in Okinawa prefecture as a base
for export to other Asian countries. Due to the rapid growth in its
mostly oil-based national income, Saudi Arabia is likely to be excluded
from receiving Japan’s official development assistance (ODA) in
2008. So Japan is scrambling to find other ways to sweeten economic
deals with the world’s number one oil exporter.
Burnishing a Tarnished
Image
Prime Minister Abe’s
trip to five Muslim countries of the Middle East was driven, at least
in part, by a desire to improve Japan’s tarnished image in the
region. Japan’s staunch support for what has internationally been
recognized as an illegal and illegitimate war in Iraq came as a shock
to many people in the Middle East. By giving its full-fledged endorsement,
Japan far outstripped some key Western allies like Germany and France
in recognizing the U.S. invasion and occupation of Iraq in 2003.
Former Japanese Prime Minister
Koizumi even resorted to the same kind of sophistry as the Bush administration
to justify the invasion. “Just because we cannot find Saddam Husein,
it doesn’t mean he doesn’t exist,” Koizumi said, at
a time when the Iraqi leader was still at large. “Therefore, we
cannot say that there are no weapons of mass destruction.” Japan
had long boasted of a relatively neutral role in Middle East affairs,
but siding with the United States damaged Tokyo’s slight advantage
in the region.
Japan’s policy toward
the Iraq War has been full of many ironies. The primary purpose of dispatching
Japanese troops to Iraq was to offer humanitarian support and help the
Iraqi people reconstruct their country. Japan withdrew its Ground Self-Defense
Forces (GSDF) from Iraq last July and has kept about 200 members of
Air Self-Defense Forces (ASDF) there. Japan’s rationale for its
reconstruction mission to Iraq might have been stronger if the GSDF
had direct contact with Iraqis and if the ASDF were not stationed at
Ali Al Salem Air Base in Kuwait mainly to serve the American occupying
forces in Iraq.
At a speech in Kyoto in early
February, Japanese Foreign Minister Taro Aso called U.S. policy in Iraq
“immature,” just days after Defense Minister Fumio Kyuma
said that the war was a “mistake.” Despite such genuine
statements, the cabinet of Prime Minister Abe, in which both ministers
are members, unanimously approved the deployment of Japan’s ASDF
in Iraq for two years beyond the current July 31 deadline.
Quandary over Iran
By avoiding the country altogether,
Shinzo Abe’s Middle East tour sent a signal to Iran. With 11.5
percent of the total, Iran is still Japan’s third largest provider
of crude oil. Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates stand in first
and second place with 31.1 percent and 25.4 percent, respectively. Despite
a friendly relationship and close ties between Tokyo and Tehran, however,
no Japanese prime minister has visited Iran since the Islamic republic
came to power in 1979.
Former Iranian President
Mohammad Khatami, visited Japan in 2000, but Japan has so far been reluctant
to pay back the visit. During his visit to Tokyo in 2000, when he announced
that his government would give Japan preference in negotiations over
the development of the Azadegan oilfield, it was as if Khatami had given
Japan special access to one of the biggest untapped reserves as a hostess
gift. Japan enthusiastically welcomed this proposal and in a matter
of month the Japan National Oil Corporation signaled its agreement to
participate in the project. But when Japan’s Inpex Corp signed
the $2 billion deal in February 2004 to develop Azadegan, the United
States tried to block the contract, which was so crucial to Japan’s
energy security. To develop and ship its own oil needs has become one
of the key objectives of Japan’s energy policy.
With the United States pushing
for greater isolation of Iran, however, Tokyo had no option but to cancel
the Azadegan contract. It continues to hope for a peaceful settlement
to Iran’s nuclear stalemate so that Inpex can regain its lost
stake in the Azadegan oil project. “Japan today enjoys good relations
with Iran,” Abe told The Washington Post in April, “and
would like to exercise whatever influence it has on the Iranians to
try and work toward a peaceful resolution of the (nuclear) issue.”
Japan has shown a keen desire
to play a role in defusing the standoff and has employed its diplomatic
skills and economic muscle to dissuade Iran from going nuclear. Japanese
Foreign Minister Taro Aso has used a special diplomatic channel with
his Iranian counterpart Manouchehr Mottaki, who once served as Tehran’s
ambassador to Tokyo from 1994 to 1999. He invited Mottaki to Japan last
year and sent Deputy Foreign Minister Mitoji Yabunaka to Iran last month.
On the stick side, Tokyo has cancelled some loans, frozen financial
transactions with Tehran, and applied punitive UN measures such as sanction
resolutions.
The United States is pushing
Japan toward greater engagement in the Middle East. Despite its support
of the Iraq fiasco, Japan’s reputation in the region is far better
than that of the United States, and many people in the Middle East still
feel positively about the role it can play. Washington wants Tokyo,
a trusted ally, to shoulder some of the economic and security burdens.
More importantly, Japan is the preferred U.S. candidate among Asian
powers to penetrate an increasingly eastward leaning Middle East. In
providing advanced technology and investments that the region desperately
needs, Japan has an advantage over India and China in this new rivalry
for Middle East influence.
Copyright © 2007, International Relations Center.
Digg
it! And spread the word!
Here is a unique chance to help this article to be read by thousands
of people more. You just Digg it, and it will appear in the home page
of Digg.com and thousands more will read it. Digg is nothing but an
vote, the article with most votes will go to the top of the page. So,
as you read just give a digg and help thousands more to read this article.
Click
here to comment
on this article