There are no breaking news at the moment

demonetisation-allen-shaw

Beyond the orgasms of patriotism and far from the rhetoric of nationalism breathes the real India, an India of flesh and blood. And no matter what amount of chest thumping some among us do, it is getting clearer by the day that it was this real India which bled white following the demonetization drive announced by the government on November 8th, 2016. And it wasn’t about ATMs or Banks or GDP, or the growth rates, it was about people. No wonder, stories of real India are the ones, which are so full of blood and flesh!

Krishna (name changed) was supposed to bring his six year old to us from a remote village near Jhansi for an imminent life and limb saving surgery. The little one had cancer of the thigh bone. She had finished chemotherapy and was due for surgery. Demonetisation delayed the sowing of Krishna’s crops, which in turn delayed his and his daughter’s return to Delhi. A previous study by us had shown that every one week delay of surgery after chemotherapy in bone cancers, increased the risk of disease coming back by two folds. We operated on Krishna’s daughter after a delay of two months! The family was happy, we weren’t, realizing very well what will happen in months to come!

By all standards Krishna’s six year old was lucky. Priya (name changed) with a similar diagnosis, a twelve year old from Balaghat (Madhya Pradesh), couldn’t make it at all to Delhi. Her father, a daily wage laborer, did all his calculations with the available funds and decided against coming for surgery. In the absence of work due to cash crunch, a prospective trip to Delhi for further treatment with us would have put him and his four other children into jeopardy. I called him the other day; he apologized in the most somber manner and told me that though Priya’s tumor has grown big, her pain is less. She was happy to be in company of her siblings. He had reconciled to fate! On coaxing to come, he disconnected, never to take our call again as if we didn’t exist.

Aslam (name changed) the twenty-year-old tall guy from a village in Moradabad had been waiting for surgery on a deformed leg. He had never walked straight and was alive to live this dream. We did a bit of geometry on his x rays and decided to give him a chance to walk again though there would be a cost of the implants used for this surgery. He willingly agreed, and borrowed a sum of thirty thousand rupees from the village money lander. The money was given to him in the afternoon of November 8th and by the end of that day Aslam’s dream and his money, had been reduced to dust. He now works to pay off his loan. He says surgery can happen in future; a future which now appears to have been swallowed by darkness.

I don’t know if demonetization will be useful to purge out black money from the veins of India but I am sure that demonetization has tried to purge the poor India! As a nation we have yet again failed the common, poor Indian. Nations are not about boundaries and maps, or about mighty Himalayas and the vast Thar. Neither is it about a tricolor or an anthem. Nations are about beating hearts and warm breaths; of dreams and hopes, of a common future. Nations can never be more important than its people, never. Nations don’t make us, we make a nation. And what use would a nation be to the likes of Krishna, Priya or Aslam if it bled them to death in the name of cleansing its economy? Why is the greater good of a nation always on the corpses of the poor? Why the hell do poor not filter through into the impervious imagination of our rulers? It evades my thought!

Prof. Shah Alam Khan, AIIMS, New Delhi (Views are Personal)

5 Comments

  1. K SHESHU BABUo says:

    These are some of many stories of people affected by sudden currency ban. Ironically, even those people who were living rather comfortably, have lost their basic necessities ( let alone comforts) due to this measure. Patients recovering from deadly diseases like cancer are forced to lose their health as they are not finding money to pay for treatment

  2. Excellent write up showing very disheartening situation currently india’s is going through mainly affecting the poorest.

  3. Unfortunate that we have to see this. Worst thing is that these wrongs are done in the name of good and we are told feel proud about it.

  4. Prof. Khan – your one page article is more true and powerful than hundreds of pages of reports by paid journalist. I am preserving this article to explain to the so called educated class of our country about the difference between Nationalism ( Rashtravad) and Desh, which is made of people rich and poor both.

  5. It is a masterpiece on the tragedy being unfolded in the name of CASHLESS NATIONALISM. East India Company 1750s onward destroyed economy of small traders, manufacturers, farmers and artisans which we called pauperization of the common Indian by the colonial masters. 7 decades after ‘Independence’ we are going through the same thing, this time executed by the HINDUTVA RULERS. BHARAT MAATAA KEE JAI!