There are no breaking news at the moment

dc-cpim1

Vijoo Krishnan recently led a team of CPI(M) and its mass organizations to the historic Dalit Asmita Yatra (culminating in Una on 15-Aug 2016). In the light of this, and participation of the party in various anti-caste uprisings in the country, Dalit Camera poses a few questions to Vijoo about the party’s role in Annihilation of Caste and their effort to bring about a Left-Ambedkarite unity.

Open Letter to Vijoo Krishnan, AIKS Joint Secretary & Permanent Invitee to CC, CPI(M)
15-Sep, 2016.

Dear Vijoo,

This letter is being written with an intention to create a meaningful discussion on the role of your Party in the struggle towards Annihilation of Caste, especially after seeing recent efforts of your Party in taking part in the various anti-Caste struggles that had arisen throughout the country in the past year with more vigour. Recently you have also personally led a team of CPI(M) and its mass organizations to the historic Una Asmita Yatra. We would also like to understand how much well intended are your efforts in bringing together the Left-Ambedkarite unity and the slogan of Neel Salaam-Lal Salaam. We would like to know your response to some of our questions and viewpoints regarding CPI(M) role in the anti-caste struggles.

1. Land Distribution

Distribution of 5 acres of Land to all Dalit families is one of the key demands of the Una Movement just like the demand of Land distribution raised by Dalits throughout these years in different parts of the country. Nothing is more ironical when your Party is supporting this in Gujarat, when in the 2 states of Kerala & West Bengal that your Party was in power, where your propaganda had been that Land reforms have been beneficial to Dalits, the per head Land distributed as per a recent RTI information (source: thewire.in – Progress Report on implementation of Land ceiling laws as on 31 December 2015) is the least in Kerala & West Bengal compared to any other states. In Kerala its .41 acres per head, in West Bengal its .33 acres per head both being at the very bottom whereas the National average being .88 acres per head.

In Kerala where your Party and Congress have been in power alternatively, there have been a plethora of land struggles by Adivasis & Dalits since 90s and continuing till date. The famous Chengara Land struggle in 2007 when Left Government was in power and which was the result of the broken promises of land distribution to Dalits & Adivasis by both the LDF and UDF Governments, was seen as an illegal struggle and land encroachment by your Party and Left Government. Your Party and Government were determined to crush the struggle and forcefully evict the families occupying the land. They were even called as Imperialist agents by your Party leaders a usual cliché dialogue used by your Party on movements or criticisms against your Party. Even the still ongoing Arippa land struggle in Kerala since more than 3 years by Adivasis & Dalits where more than 300 families have occupied the land whose lease period was over, was attacked locally by an alliance of Congress, BJP, CPI, CPI(M) and the local people on reasons notwithstanding. The local people was told not even to give water to those protestors by the then CPI MLA and which was completely justified by your local Party leaders. Their demand for 10 acres of land was abruptly rejected by your local Party leadership as unrealistic demand. Even the 1957 Land Reforms bill by the First Communist Government in newly formed Kerala despite its effort in breaking the landlord system had given the least priority to agricultural labourers (who were mostly Dalits) than the landlords who were the upper caste Nair community.

This can be understood from the section 70 of 1957 bill which states:

70. Assignment of rights over land vested in Government.-

(1) The land board may assign rights over lands surrendered to the Government under section 64 or section 65 (section 64 is surrender of excess lands above land ceiling and section 65 is surrender of excess land received as gifts)    or the rights over land vested in Government under section 49 (section 49 is purchase to be ineffective in certain cases including the failing of lump sum or clearing the arrears for buying the land by the tenant from the landlord) to persons who have no lands or have lands in extent than the ceiling area and in doing so the board shall have regard to the following considerations in determining the order of priority for such assignment:-

  • a tenant whose land has been resumed under section 6 (section 6 deals wth taking the land from tenant in case of utilizing it for temple or mosque etc, or for building purpose by landlord or for self cultivation by landlord)
  • a landlord who has lost the rights over lands on account of the provisions of section 40 (section 40 – Permanent tenants deemed to have purchased land on Peasants’ day ) and who does not have lands in his actual possession more than 3 acres of double crop nilam or its equalent.
  • co-operative farming societies whose members are agricultural labourers who have no land
  • agricultural labourers who have no land except kudikidappu
  • adjoining cultivators

Land to tiller” was the main slogan throughout the peasant struggles prior to 1957, in which Dalits took part in large numbers and sacrificed their lives also in those struggles. But post those struggles land distribution to Dalits were the least priority and had to be dependent on surplus Land distribution in which huge portion of the land declared as surplus in the first Govt time today are mostly in Court cases. All efforts were to maintain them as agricultural labourers itself by only talking about their wages and rights through unions (In West Bengal even this union was absent as the Government tried to portray that there was no agricultural labourers, just like WB Government told there were no OBCs in the state during Mandal period), whereas huge plantations held land even after lease period.

The subsequent land reforms done by both LDF and UDF in Kerala only helped accumulate land through the land ceiling act and other evasive provisions in the act by the dominant caste communities (by converting their land to plantation, religious trusts, family trusts etc.) and betraying Dalits & Adivasis of land, instead ghettoizing them to colonies and slums in Kerala. One best example is how the family of V.R Krishna Iyer, the law and home minister in 1957 Communist Govt consolidated its land through family trust. Even your party’s propaganda of distribution of 10 cents of land to Dalits were bluff, when actually Dalits had to pay for those lands.

A study conducted by Kerala Institute of Local Administration (an autonomous training, research and consultancy organization constituted under the Ministry of Local Self Government, Government of Kerala) reveals that 55% from the scheduled caste are living in an appalling condition in 26,198 colonies (This doesn’t include Christian dalits). The census 2011 shows that among 15 lakh Dalit households, around 12% stay in dilapidated state of houses, whereas 43% stay in just livable state of houses.

Beyond the rhetoric of “Agrarian Revolution” which will supposedly break the Caste system, CPI(M) has not yet provided a comprehensive view on even what this “Agrarian Revolution” will be or how it will be implemented rather lamenting/hiding their failures under the limitations of the bourgeois-landlord system in India.

Even West Bengal, were Left had ruled for 34 years and your Party upheld Land distribution as its biggest achievement especially to Dalits and Adivasis, actually your intellectuals and Government created a myth just like the Gujarat development myth by twisting the numbers and partial facts. The distribution of land resulted in around only .33 acres of land per head, because of which many of them later quit agriculture and had to migrate to other states as daily wage labourers due to the inability to sustain livelihood on agriculture with those insufficient land holdings or had to sell it back to the previous landowning upper castes. According to the National Sample Survey Organisation (NSSO) report, 2004-05, there were more than 12 lakh families in West Bengal who do not get adequate food during various months in a year. Among the rural population particularly the toiler peasants’ including agricultural labourers are in deep crisis. 106 families out of 1000 families remain starved or semi starved in rural Bengal. (The figure for AP was 6 out of 1000, Assam 17 out of 1000, Bihar 20 out of 1000, Orissa 48 out of 1000). Most of these sections consist of Dalits, backward castes, muslims. According to the National Sample Survey in 2001, While 58.3% rural poor families, comprising mainly the families of agricultural workers or sharecroppers, owned only 6% of the land in India, in West Bengal the poor peasants’ families comprising 55.4% owned only 3.9% land. In 2001, 39.2% agricultural families had no land. The same survey states that the all India figure of the landless peasants was 35.1% in that year (Source: Ajit Narayan Bose, Paschim Banglar Arthaniti o Rajniti). As per census 2011, out of 1 crore Dalit households in WB, 15% households stay in dilapidated houses, while 55% household stay in just livable houses.

Beyond the rhetoric of “Agrarian Revolution” which will supposedly break the Caste system, CPI(M) has not yet provided a comprehensive view on even what this “Agrarian Revolution” will be or how it will be implemented rather lamenting/hiding their failures under the limitations of the bourgeois-landlord system in India.

2. Manual Scavenging

One of the revolutionary outcomes of the Una Asmita Yatra was the abandoning of the traditional work of skinning the cows entitled upon Dalits by the Brahmanical system through pledges during the Yatra itself. Similarly Manual scavenging has been a cruel reality were Dalits have been engaged throughout the country, which like many other parties and groups your party also have been campaigning to abolish. But the reality is that the states where your Party had been in rule, itself are not free from Manual scavenging.

As per the the latest Socio-Economic Caste Census data released on July 3, 2015, 17,332 households among 6.9 Lakhs household involved in manual scavenging in Tripura. The percentage of Tripura in terms of the number of families involved in manual scavenging was the highest for any states in 2011 census as well as the latest 2015 census, beating other states like Bihar, UP, Karnataka, Maharashtra, MP by long distance. As per Socio Economic and Caste Census (SECC) 2011, there were 13,687 families who depend on manual scavenging in Kerala. As per the survey by National Scheduled Castes Finance and Development Corporation in 2011, Manual scavenging was very much reality in West Bengal. The findings from the work undertaken by Safai Karmachari Andolan also confirms the existence of manual scavenging in Kerala & West Bengal.

3. Atrocities on Dalits

  • The major trigger for the Gujarat uprising was the brutal violence unleashed publicly on Dalits which have been carried out since centuries. Especially as a result of assertion by Dalits, the atrocities by dominant castes have only increased. Your Party also have a long history of such violence through the state machinery as well as through your party machinery. In 1979, the West Bengal Left Government had unleashed state violence in Marichjhapi, when refugees from Bangladesh who were majorly Dalits and people from other marginalized communities were brutally murdered by the state when before coming to power rehabilitating them was one of your key campaign as part of elections, whereas at the same time the rehabilitation of Bhadralok Refugees were taken full care by the State and today settled well in different parts of the State and country.

The AIDWA office secretary even told that they can’t involve since BSP was involved. So the double standards your Party has been showing and always appearing as saviours of Dalits, how much commitment is there beyond developing your own Organizational/Electoral base and only when there is a media sensationalism in scope?

  • Chitralekha, a dalit woman auto driver is a living example of victimhood of your Party’s caste violence and harassment even today as this letter is being written, her courageous fight to stand against your mighty Party and its machinery in Kerala for more than 10 years is turned a blind eye even today by your Leadership. During a recent interaction at the University of Hyderabad, your PB member Brinda Karat told she was unaware of this issue and usual evasive answer that if some wrong doing is done, the culprits will be punished when asked about Chitralekha. But even after that local Party members are trying to make sure she doesn’t build the house allotted to her by previous Government by creating all sorts of troubles. It was hard to believe that Brinda Karat is not aware of this issue, because when Brinda Karat was giving a speech in January on women violence in Trivandrum, hardly 3kms from there, Chitralekha was on a day night protest in front of secretariat. Also a complaint regarding the ongoing violence even after so many years was submitted to your Party’s Control Commission headed by another PB Member S. Ramachandran Pillai in 2013 itself, for which after 1 year a reply came saying the issue was enquired with local party members and this is just another made up story to tarnish Party with no detailed investigation conducted. In her recent struggles the CPI(M) propagandists in FB was doing character assassination of her and spreading all sorts of lies against her. They have also adopted a new mode of attack that initially mistake was done against her (though Party and Party paper screamed in 2005 that this was a media make up and no apology was ever done to her or actions taken against the culprits), but now these are all drama.
  • In Karnataka, when the brutal Kambalapalli massacre of Dalits by upper castes occurred in the year 2000, your Party member and an influential advocate of Karnataka, Shankarappa fought the case for the accused upper castes in sessions court and got the accused acquitted there. Even today the accused are scot free and dalit organizations and those families are fighting for justice. Shankarappa later served as your Party’s Lawyers Organizations State President for several years have taken up cases of your mass organizations.
  • In 2009, during the rule of your Left Government, brutal police atrocities was unleashed in the Dalit colonies in Varkala where even women were also not spared for the mistake of attending the activities of DHRM which was then accused of a murder that took place in Varkala a few days after Shiv Sena activists attacked DHRM. Many innocent DHRM activists were arrested without any proof on being involved in the murder and even women were attacked and abused. The relatives when met with the then Home Minister and your PB member Kodiyeri Balakrishnan, they were portrayed as terrorists. This situation was no different from the conditions of Dalits who along with muslims being the most powerless sections languish in Indian jails on false charges and ignored by all pillars of so called democracy in this country.
  • The dalit women laborers of Kannan Devan Hills Plantation who formed a union called “Pomplai orumai” to fight for the right to bonuses, fair wages and against exploitative working conditions also challenged the patriarchal established trade unions which they felt were not representing their position at the negotiating table. Despite CITU and AITUC settling the issue of a bonus without consulting workers, the women workers went on strike in huge numbers and this exposed CITU’s lack of commitment to workers. It showed their complete lack of touch let alone serious engagement with the democratic aspirations of these dalit women as the rank-and-file of the union who ought to be the primary decision makers around issues affecting their working conditions. CITU’s actual operation was further revealed to be in connivance with management, as the women had to face different sorts of harassment, including  threats, directly from the CITU and AITUC trade union members on behalf of management. This clearly shows that the primary interest of these unions are not in raising relevant labor issues but in maintaining their hegemony as a union at the cost of oppressing the workers. After the initial victory of Pomplai Orumai in getting a bonus hike with no support from the traditional unions, the group planned to strike for just wages. At this stage a concerted effort was made to get everyone to leave Pomplai Orumai and to join a parallel token protest organized by CITU and AITUC for the same issue of salary hike, to distract public and media attention from the pomplai orumai movement. The women were also manipulated, intimidated and pressured by CITU through three major ways.
  • Most workers received loans at exorbitant rates of interest from the CITU affiliated union, and their indebtedness to the union was used as a tool by which CITU controlled these women and their families. The workers needed to divert most of their monthly wages towards paying interest on loans to the union. With a union like this, who needs management and moneylenders
  • CPI(M) and Congress also pressurized women leaders by filing false criminal cases against them, which includes a case of abetting sexual violence filed on a woman leader of Pomplai Orumai. These cases persist till date.

Before the death of Rohith your party did not come up with any such statements or articles on the plight of the scholars who were targetted and expelled,  nor did your party participate in any of their struggles. But now, when the movements have mobilized national attention, you are all over the place.

  • They have also exploited the personal situations of women leaders, and pressured them through their own family members and husbands in order to try break the unity of Pomplai orumai. The women were threatened and individually isolated until they felt they would not able to fight alone against these big political parties. With these above kinds of pressure and intimidation, the established unions were largely successful at breaking the unity of Pomplai Orumai. Rather than ensuring justice to the workers from the most marginalized community and who are working under the most exploiting of conditions, CITU and CPI(M) is trying to break such genuine efforts, and persuade them to join their own organization and appropriate their movement, to consolidate their own organization and to show to the public that CITU or CPI(M) is the savior of them
  • In your very current Left Government itself, 2 Dalit sisters on the mistake that their father was a Congress member were harassed and when they questioned this going to a Party office in a very strong Party area, they were arrested along with their one and half year daughter on very dubious grounds, and your CM Pinarayi Vijayan who is another PB member brushed aside this saying that this is something for police to answer and later even justified this on legal basis as nothing unnatural. One of the sisters even attempted suicide on account of insults by CPI(M) Leaders An Shamseer and P P Divya in media channel discussion on same issue and later her suicide attempt was even mocked publicly by your Party State leader P.Jayarajan.
  • When your Party suddenly woke up to the suicide of Rohit Vemula, seeing a political opportunity against BJP, like other Parties have been doing, the truth was that your students movement SFI hardly did any mobilization across the country beyond token statements when dalit suicides occurred previously in HCU or EFLU. Before the death of Rohith your party did not come up with any such statements or articles on the plight of the scholars who were targetted and expelled,  nor did your party participate in any of their struggles. But now, when the movements have mobilized national attention, you are all over the place.
  • Even when your Party was very active with no qualms to share dias with Sushma Swaraj for Anna Hazare protest in Jantar Mantar or later active for the protests for justice for Delhi gang rape in Jantar Mantar, at the same Jantar Mantar when a month long protest by the families of girls of Bhagana in the year 2014 happened who were gangraped by the dominant Jats at the same Jantar Mantar, your party and women organization could only take a token step of submitting memorandum. Even when supporters of your own Party reached out to some of your All India level leaders and even went to AIDWA office to request support when police lathi charge was happening on protestors, your Party leaders just evaded showing the token memorandum. The AIDWA office secretary even told that they can’t involve since BSP was involved. So the double standards your Party has been showing and always appearing as saviours of Dalits, how much commitment is there beyond developing your own Organizational/Electoral base and only when there is a media sensationalism in scope?

4. CPI(M) view on the role of Caste System

CPI(M) view of Caste system is based on just the practical outcomes in the most obvious forms of discrimination and oppressions such as untouchability, social exclusion etc. Almost no mainstream Parties would justify these openly except some rare cases and would have to condemn these openly even though they don’t want to. Also there are parties including yours which would have done struggles against untouchability and other social exclusion in various states. But beyond all these, the ideological and historic view on the role of Caste system is seldom seen anywhere in your Party documents. On the contrary, the historic role of Caste System in Indian society is rather viewed as progressive in developing the society in all spheres from an uncivilized state. This can be seen in one of CPI(M) founders and former General Secretary of Party EMS Namboothiripad’s book “Keralam, Malayalee Motherland” where he mentions the role of Caste system in developing Kerala society especially but also Indian society:

Not only for Kerala but for entire India, Caste was a big contribution from the Arya Brahmins. The Caste system in India had the same basis of Slavery system in Europe. Today we object and hate Caste system. Just like Slavery system, Caste system also exploited and oppressed lakhs and lakhs of common people. But just like Slavery system, Caste system have also helped the human society progress from the uncivilized state in which they were in.

The implementation of Caste system is a very significant event in the social progress in India. It was when the people were divided into different castes based on their occupation, that agriculture, handicraft, trade, arts, literature, war skills etc. started developing. The essence of Caste system were – son learning the occupation of father, developing the desire in each child of getting trained and gaining expertise in family occupation, to gain expertise in the family occupation and live comfortably etc. As a result the men and women of each caste got the opportunity to develop their occupation; each generation have added to their practices and knowledge gained from the previous generation, new knowledge and their practical implementation. Like that each occupation started developing. Just like ancient Greece, Roman and Egypt civilizations were built on the foundation of slavery system, Hindu civilization was built on the foundation of Caste system. It was on the exploitation of Shudra and Chandala that Vaishya did agriculture, trade and hence increased the wealth of himself and the people. Kshatriyas were able to develop warfare, learnt making new weapons and able to build empires by attacking other land on the foundation of the exploited condition of the lower castes. It was caste system which enabled the rishis and brahmins to create and teach vedas, upanishads, myths, science, performing arts etc. In short, the superior Arsha Bharatha culture, the ancient hindu empires, the handicraft goods which attracted foreigners and their centre, the self-sufficient villages all grew from the foundation of the Caste system.

The ideological and historic view on the role of Caste system is seldom seen anywhere in your Party documents. on the contrary, the historic role of Caste System in Indian society is rather viewed as progressive in developing the society in all spheres from an uncivilized state.

But Ambedkar had lucidly stated how rather Caste System with its division of labourers is detrimental to any society and has actually stagnated the Indian society in his seminal book – Annihilation of Caste:

This division of labour is not spontaneous, it is not based on natural aptitudes. Social and individual efficiency requires us to develop the capacity of an individual to the point of competency to choose and to make his own career. This principle is violated in the Caste System, in so far as it involves an attempt to appoint tasks to individuals in advance—selected not on the basis of trained original capacities, but on that of the social status of the parents.

Looked at from another point of view, this stratification of occupations which is the result of the Caste System is positively pernicious. Industry is never static. It undergoes rapid and abrupt changes. With such changes, an individual must be free to change his occupation. Without such freedom to adjust himself to changing circumstances, it would be impossible for him to gain his livelihood. Now the Caste System will not allow Hindus to take to occupations where they are wanted, if they do not belong to them by heredity. If a Hindu is seen to starve rather than take to new occupations not assigned to his Caste, the reason is to be found in the Caste System. By not permitting readjustment of occupations, Caste becomes a direct cause of much of the unemployment we see in the country.

As a form of division of labour, the Caste system suffers from another serious defect. The division of labour brought about by the Caste System is not a division based on choice. Individual sentiment, individual preference, has no place in it. It is based on the dogma of predestination. Considerations of social efficiency would compel us to recognize that the greatest evil in the industrial system is not so much poverty and the suffering that it involves, as the fact that so many persons have callings [=occupations]which make no appeal to those who are engaged in them. Such callings constantly provoke one to aversion, ill will, and the desire to evade.

5. Brahmanism

Ambedkar had considered Hinduism/Brahmanism as roots of Fascism in India. Ambedkar had stated unequivocally through his in depth study of Hinduism that this religion was the basis for one of the most evil socio-economic system – Caste system. The Sangh Parivar is only a branch which had grown from this roots of Hinduism and not a deviation. Whereas your Party till now doesn’t have any analysis on Brahmanism either in your Party documents related to Caste or your Party program. Rather the general view in your Party is that Hinduism is a liberal religion with Caste system along with superstitions as a “social evil” problems which every religion would have. This can be seen well in the article by your Party General Secretary Sitaram Yechury in your Party organ People’s Democracy “PSEUDO HINDUISM EXPOSED – THE REALITY OF SAFFRON BRIGADE’S MYTHS” where he elaborates this point about Sangh Parivar being a deviation from Hinduism and Hinduism as liberal. He quotes Adi Sankara (who was the ideological leader in defeating the egalitarian Buddhism and reviving or strengthening Brahmanism), Vivekananda (who firmly supported Caste system and who just wanted to reform the Caste system, also warned against conversion to other religions), and Bhagavad Gita for this. He says :-

This is the meaning of the BJP’s invocation of the “Hindu sentiment” (commenting on Golwalkar’s book).  This runs contrary to the vast diversity and majority of Hindu opinion which has been guided more by Vivekananda and Adi Sankara than by Golwalkar or the present day self-incarnations of the S.S. put together.  While Adi Sankara was to constantly preach that as different rivers flow through different courses to merge in the same ocean, so do different individuals through different faiths merge with the same almighty.  Vivekananda had said ,  “If anybody dreams of the exclusive survival of his own religion and the destruction of others, I pity him from the bottom of my heart and point out to him that upon the banner of every religion will soon be written, in spite of resistance; help, and not fight harmony and peace and not dissension“.

Above all, take the Bhagavad Gita which says, “Whatever celestial form a devotee seeks to worship with faith, I stabilise the faith of that particular devotee in that particular form.” (Chapter VII (21). Whatever be the colour of the cow, the milk is always white.

The R.S.S’s Hindu Rashtra is in total contradiction with such wisdom.”

How can Annihilation of caste be possible without even understanding Brahmanism and as part of that with serious critique of Brahmanism at all spheres?

Maintaining Brahmanical hegemony in the cultural spaces and daily life has been another way by which Brahmanical hegemony had been stamped in this society. Your Party also was never seen in opposing the public display of Brahmanical symbols and images in so called “secular” public institutions or as part of the regular practice. The festival of Onam which was declared a State Festival in Kerala, which was supposed to be celebration of the Bahujan king Mahabali is today a depiction of extreme Brahmanical image and vegetarianism. The celebration of all Brahmanical festivals even in university spaces is left unchallenged or undebated by your Organizations. SFI never supported such cultural struggles by Organizations such as ASA in these campuses especially on festivals like Deepavali. Your party cadres were involved in celebrating Sri Krishna Jayanti last year in Kerala and even other interventions among the Hindu community in a view to counter RSS efforts, though your party is now attempting to refute this. In a recent Onam celebrations program conducted in Rashtrapati Bhavan in this month by Kairali in co-operation with the current Left Government, the programs started with the recitation of verses from Rigveda. CPI(M)’s one of the tallest leaders and previous CM E.K Nayanar even gave Bhagavad Gita to Pope when he was given bible by Pope which is nothing but an hegemonic notion that Bhagavad Gita is representative of the culture/religion of India. The muslim league minister in the previous government was witch hunted and termed communal by the public including your party for exercising his democratic right to not light the traditional candle in a public function. These all seem to be in synch with the above understanding of Hinduism as liberal and Sangh Parivar only as the one which needs to be fought against. How can Annihilation of caste be possible without even understanding Brahmanism and as part of that with serious critique of Brahmanism at all spheres?

What is the reason for such lack of Dalit leadership and intellectuals in your Party, whereas numerous Dalit leaders and intellectuals who have made significant contributions to the political process in this country have come from Ambedkarite movements?

6. Representation of Dalits in CPI(M) Leadership

One of the significant aspects of the political processes happening currently has been the stress on Dalit movements and struggles under the Dalit Leadership. These struggles have posed serious challenge to Hindutva Fascism as well as is foundation the Brahmanical hegemony. But the question of Dalit leadership whether in your Party or your People’s Representatives and among your Party intellectuals, has always been ignored by your Party. Almost 1/3rd of your Polit Bureau members till now have been Brahmins, and in the remaining most of them have been from Landowning dominant castes. There has not been a single Dalit till now in your Polit Bureau and even a Muslim came to your PB after 44 years. Even your intellectuals are also mostly from the Brahmin and other Savarna communities. Even in West Bengal where Dalits are numerically the 2nd after UP, the representation of Dalits in the Central Leadership and State leadership has been abysmally low compared to its population whereas the minority Bhadralok community heavily dominates your Party leadership like it dominated every sphere of West Bengal State and Civil society. Even a People’s representative from Kerala or West Bengal from Dalit community how tall a leader he/she is, also could get elected from reserved constituencies, the other instances being very rare.

What is the reason for such lack of Dalit leadership and intellectuals in your Party, whereas numerous Dalit leaders and intellectuals who have made significant contributions to the political process in this country have come from Ambedkarite movements?

Regards,
Dalit Camera

15-Sep, 2016.

First published in Dalit Camera 

3 Comments

  1. K SHESHU BABU says:

    Major problems of communist Marxists mainstream party is the lack of proper mechanism to arrest the penetration if brahminism into the rank and file of the party from top to bottom. That is why, it has not been able to solve any of dalit problem except ‘ lip service’. In order to be effective, the whole leadership must be changed from brahminical functionaries and dalits and Muslims must be given the charge of top leadership.

  2. Regarding the land distribution, there is a flaw in their analysis. When they got the figures about kerala and WB correct but failed to recognize that it was based on available surplus area, i.e the ration is area distributed from surplus and number of beneficiaries. As per RTI (https://docs.google.com/document/d/1nwu_Vm4Ch04lqKiL8RX2iIoQAS8sSh1u9aej-c-hv3w/edit) one could see that when land reform failed nation wide it WB was an expection. Kerala is one of the state which setup land tribunals for easy settlement of case.The Draft National Land Reforms Policy has credited West Bengal and Kerala for having best performed in surplus land distribution.

  3. BS Sharma Milk plant workers union says:

    All the parties including left has used the expllited people specially the dalits as bait to catch the fish. The BSP also used these Dalits and fell victim to brahmanism. But the role of left thinkers,activists and parties is hopelessly prooved mere lip sympathy.I agree 100 percent with the dalit camera version. All is futile tll the Dalits,the downtrodens,women are empowered with political leadership and adeqate role in ruling the country and to be capable of revolting for their right based on their own strength. I support ur version. We should keep ready our people i.e. Dalits and sypathisers to adequated deffend against any type of injustice.